Mashed potatoes are almost expected as part of a holiday spread. In fact, I would argue that mashed potatoes appear on more holiday tables than a turkey or roast, because even vegans will serve them. But, if you’ve been living more ancestrally and you’ve been keeping your carbs low, you may be looking for a low-carb alternative to mashed potatoes.
Whether you’re trying to lower your carb intake or just switch things up, why not try a different vegetable mash this season? Not to worry, each of these options makes a great vehicle for gravy, and we’re all in it for the gravy anyway, aren’t we?
Carbs in Mashed Potatoes
One cup of mashed potatoes contains 36.9 g of carbohydrates.1 After you subtract the fiber, you’re left with 33.6 g net carbs in mashed potatoes.
If you’re limiting carbs, just one serving of traditional mashed potatoes doesn’t leave room for much else.
Low-carb and Keto Alternatives to Traditional Mashed Potatoes
Cauliflower: 3.2g net carbs per cup
Broccoli: 3.6g net carbs per cup
Spaghetti squash: 5.5g net carbs per cup
Turnips: 6.1g net carbs per cup
Pumpkin: 6.9g net carbs per cup
Carrots: 8.7g net carbs per cup
Rutabaga: 8.9g net carbs per cup
Celery Root: 11.6g net carbs per cup
Butternut squash: 13.6g net carbs per cup
Parsnip: 17.4g net carbs per cup
Acorn squash: 21g net carbs per cup
Sweet potato: 22.8g net carbs per cup
How to Prep Your Mash or Purée
Boiling or Steaming
This option will work for any of the above veggies. Simply peel, slice, or chop your vegetable into uniform 1-inch pieces and fill a pot with water and bring to a boil on the stovetop. Carefully place the veggies in the water if boiling them or lower them into a steamer basket if steaming. The total time will vary depending upon the vegetable and how large you cut them, but once they are fork-tender, strain out the water and place the soft veggie pieces back into the pot.
Roasting will work best for winter squash and sweet potato. Cut your squash in half or cubes and drizzle with avocado oil. Place on a sheet pan and roast in a 375-degree oven until tender. Scoop out the flesh.
Place your veggies back in the pot you boiled them in or in a large bowl if you roasted them. Use a potato masher to begin to mash the veggies.
Add a few tablespoons of butter and a little milk or dairy-free milk as needed to mash into a smooth texture. Some vegetables will mash more smoothly than others so the amount of time this takes will vary. Season with salt and pepper and you’re ready to eat!
To Mash Your Veggies in a Food Processor
Place the boiled or roasted veggies in a food processor. Add butter and pulse or turn the processor on and begin processing the vegetables. Add a little milk or dairy-free milk if needed to achieve the proper consistency. Season with salt and pepper to taste.
Flavorful Additions to Add to Your Mash
Fresh herbs of any kind, but especially rosemary, thyme, sage, or parsley
Are Potatoes Keto?
Because potatoes contain over 30 g of carbs per cup, potatoes are not considered keto. You would have to eat an extremely small, unsatisfying amount of potatoes to stay in ketosis.
A food blogger, recipe developer, and personal chef based in Missouri, Priscilla specializes in low-carb, Paleo, gluten-free, keto, vegetarian, and low FODMAP cooking. See what she’s cooking on Priscilla Cooks, and follow her food adventures on Instagram and Pinterest.