Meet Mark

Let me introduce myself. My name is Mark Sisson. I’m 63 years young. I live and work in Malibu, California. In a past life I was a professional marathoner and triathlete. Now my life goal is to help 100 million people get healthy. I started this blog in 2006 to empower people to take full responsibility for their own health and enjoyment of life by investigating, discussing, and critically rethinking everything we’ve assumed to be true about health and wellness...

Tell Me More
Stay Connected
September 24 2018

Dear Mark: Diet to Get Lean, Exercise to Get Healthy?

By Mark Sisson
6 Comments

For today’s edition of Dear Mark, I’ll be discussing the role of exercise alone in weight and fat loss. If it seems like I’ve been harping on this same topic for a couple weeks now, it’s only because it’s so important to identify both the mainstream (“You must exercise ten minutes for each Oreo you eat.”) and alternative misconceptions (“Exercise has no effect on body composition.”) about exercise. Exercise—all by itself—actually can help you lose body fat, even if it has less to do with “burning calories” than other factors.

Let’s take a look:

So basically, correct diet makes you lean. Correct exercise makes you healthy.

Yes and no. Diet is the biggest factor in weight loss. but in order for the weight you lose to be primarily fat and the weight you gain to be primarily muscle, you really should exercise.

There are a good number of studies in which an exercise intervention alone actually improved body composition. In most of these, it’s very likely that the exercising groups spontaneously altered their eating patterns. The point is that they didn’t set out to change their dietary intake, if any change occurred. They set out to exercise and that was it—and it was enough to make them leaner.

Let’s keep it to just this year alone. What are some 2018 studies into the effects only exercising can have on body composition?

In obese adolescent girls, a 12-week strength and aerobic training program (3 days a week) dropped body fat by almost 4%, while also reducing glucose, insulin, and inflammatory markers.

In obese teens, eccentric stationary cycling is better at reducing fat mass than concentric stationary cycling. But both programs lowered body fat without altering food intake.

Teens might be especially sensitive to the fat-reducing effects of exercise. For one, teen males don’t compensate for all the calories they burn during training. Even obese teens who engage in a single acute bout of high intensity interval training show reduced food reward (junk food and food in general becomes less enticing than normal) and, despite subjective appetite remaining high, eat less food than obese teens who don’t do the HIIT session.

It works in adults, too. Among young women with obesity, a 12-week circuit training program with no changes to diet reduced body fat, body weight, and BMI compared to the control group.

In obese women, high-intensity circuit training reduced body weight and body fat while increasing lean mass. Those who did not participate in the exercise program got heavier, fatter, and saw their waist circumference expand.

One recent study found that weight training was more likely than other forms of training to reduce appetite and improve weight/fat loss, thanks to its unique effects on appetite hormones. That’s been my experience, both with myself and when working with others. A regular diet of heavy strength training just works best. You’re hungry, but for the right things. Chronic cardio has a different effect—increased cravings for refined carbs. The classic sight at cafes in Malibu was always the hordes of spandex-clad cyclists and runners cramming themselves with pastries and cookies.

Even among the perpetually obese, those who exercise on a regular basis have less region-specific body fat (if you measure the fat percentage of a particular region of the body, it’s lower in obese people who exercise) and less overall body fat.

Not all studies find big changes in body weight. That’s normal. That’s to be expected. But what they do consistently find in exercise-only studies is that training reduces fat mass, even when it doesn’t reduce overall body weight.

Now, just imagine what you can accomplish with a good diet and regular training and physical activity. Oh, and throw some stress reduction, good sleep, regular circadian rhythmicity in there for good measure.

What’s your experience been with exercise alone for fat—not just weight—loss?

Thanks for reading, everyone. Take care.

References:

Wong A, Sanchez-gonzalez MA, Son WM, Kwak YS, Park SY. The Effects of a 12-Week Combined Exercise Training Program on Arterial Stiffness, Vasoactive Substances, Inflammatory Markers, Metabolic Profile, and Body Composition in Obese Adolescent Girls. Pediatr Exerc Sci. 2018;:1-7.

Julian V, Thivel D, Miguet M, et al. Eccentric cycling is more efficient in reducing fat mass than concentric cycling in adolescents with obesity. Scand J Med Sci Sports. 2018;

Shakiba E, Sheikholeslami-vatani D, Rostamzadeh N, Karim H. The type of training program affects appetite-regulating hormones and body weight in overweight sedentary men. Appl Physiol Nutr Metab. 2018;

Thivel D, Finlayson G, Miguet M, et al. Energy depletion by 24-h fast leads to compensatory appetite responses compared with matched energy depletion by exercise in healthy young males. Br J Nutr. 2018;120(5):583-592.

Miguet M, Fillon A, Khammassi M, et al. Appetite, energy intake and food reward responses to an acute High Intensity Interval Exercise in adolescents with obesity. Physiol Behav. 2018;195:90-97.

Kim JW, Ko YC, Seo TB, Kim YP. Effect of circuit training on body composition, physical fitness, and metabolic syndrome risk factors in obese female college students. J Exerc Rehabil. 2018;14(3):460-465.

Batrakoulis A, Jamurtas AZ, Georgakouli K, et al. High intensity, circuit-type integrated neuromuscular training alters energy balance and reduces body mass and fat in obese women: A 10-month training-detraining randomized controlled trial. PLoS ONE. 2018;13(8):e0202390.

Santi A, Bosch TA, Bantle AE, et al. High Body Mass Index Masks Body Composition Differences in Physically Active Versus Sedentary Participants. Metab Syndr Relat Disord. 2018;

Drenowatz C, Hand GA, Sagner M, Shook RP, Burgess S, Blair SN. The Prospective Association between Different Types of Exercise and Body Composition. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2015;47(12):2535-41.

TAGS:  dear mark

If you'd like to add an avatar to all of your comments click here!

6 thoughts on “Dear Mark: Diet to Get Lean, Exercise to Get Healthy?”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. I always feel like the psychological cycle that exercise puts me in is the most beneficial part. It’s hard to know how much is hormonal and how much is mindset, but when I’ve had a good exercise session, I really want to make good choices around food and lifestyle.

  2. Is the cookie eating cyclist a reference to Phil Gaimon?

    Interesting about weight training and HIIT. I thought it was odd that I wasn’t as hungry after my PT sessions but I was always famished after a swim… There’s my answer. I have done the opposite recently – not much exercise but eating Primally and doing most of the good lifestyle things and losing about 1kg a week. But that could have been muscle and fat I was losing. Last week I had a PT session, 2 hour tai chi class and lots of walking and I lost about 0.5kg… when in the past I’ve been doing a good bit of exercise I think it stopped me getting fatter but didn’t help me get any slimmer!

  3. Good article Mark and so topical. I have staff, mostly in their 30’s punishing themselves at the gym with personal trainers, kick boxing, spin classes or their own programs. Nothing really wrong with their exercise, but they destroy the potential success with poor eating choices, counting calories, high carbs, sugary desserts, grazing, ordering in bad food, etc. Always a new fad or short cut such as cleanse diets, juice diets, wine diet (kinda liked that one) one staff person going to Thailand on an expensive retreat to fix her weight issue. So much mid-information out there.

    The old story, you can’t outwork a bad diet. They are starting to ask questions as to how I keep lean at 58, why I eat an Avacado at lunch every day and intermittent fast so hopefully in time, they will see the light and I will enlighten them about the Primal Blueprint and ancestral lifestyle.

  4. In my youth, exercise helped me lose weight. In adulthood, 35 or so on, it has always made me hungrier and I eat enough to actually gain weight. I have never figured out how to exercise and eat and avoid that hunger. I still exercise because its healthy but sometimes I wish I would stop and just focus on losing those 15 pounds. I am recently exercising more moderately and trying to eat moderately and I an inching down at the rate of 1 pound or so every four weeks. I just wish I could go enjoy a day long bike ride without severe hunger for two days.

  5. I find exercise increases my hunger, for sure. I still do it, because I like the muscle definition and mood benefits, but I no longer push myself with any long or intense sessions. In my experience, as a mid 30s female, I find better results through a good diet and sleep. I will never sacrifice sleep for an early morning training session – crazy talk

    In my 20s I was addicted to exercise because I had this fear that I would never be able to maintain my physique without it. Come to find out, while I’m not as small as I used to be, I now have better muscle definition and proportions (waist to hip ratio) with significantly less exercise. In retrospect, I think I was destroying any chance for muscle growth through too much training. Finally, I think women are trained from a young age to push to be as small as possible. And women get fixated on a clothing size, even if their bone structure would look better with more meat on it…

    My husband as another reference point, does crossfit style workouts 3x per week. He is in amazing shape, with great muscle and low body fat. However, when he doesn’t train, he seems to lose his appetite. For him, even doing body weight, HIIT workouts, it increases his hunger, which helps him put on and keep good muscle (a good 15 lb fluctuation).

    In summary, I have come to think that exercise regulates your appetite and helps your body shift into a healthy weight. It helps me deal with stress and anxiety, while reminding me how amazing food can taste (nothing taste better than a good burger after a long hike!). I enjoy exercise but no longer have to have it. And, removing all the extra exercise makes for lots of time to pursue other hobbies.

  6. Lifting heavy weights, full body 3-4 days a week utilizing compound lifts is far superior to LISS or chronic cardio for weight loss and ideal body composition. One increases your metabolism and the other actually slows it down.