Stay Connected
August 27 2011

Creamy Ranch Dressing

By Worker Bee
77 Comments

It’s an undeniable fact that homemade recipes usually don’t taste exactly the same as a store-bought version of the same food. This is most clearly the case with processed foods, which are especially hard to re-create exactly in a home kitchen. This is a good thing – do you really want your kitchen pantry stocked with ingredients like soybean oil, phosphoric acid, monosodium glutamate (MSG), disodium phosphate and the most mysterious ingredient of all, “artificial flavors”? These ingredients are only half of what you would need to make Ranch dressing that tastes exactly like it was poured from a shelf-stable bottle.

Ranch dressing is a much-loved condiment, one that many people remember fondly after they stop eating processed foods. But honestly, is the odd way that bottled Ranch dressing coats your tongue and the weird, metallic aftertaste something you really, truly miss?

If the answer is no, but you still find yourself wishing you had a creamy side to dip your chicken wings in or a rich dressing to pour on your salad, then you’re gonna love this homemade version of Ranch. Made from entirely recognizable and pronounceable ingredients, this dressing is creamy, tangy and loaded with fresh herbs and dried spices (plus a secret ingredient) that make it a dressing worthy of any chicken wing you throw at it.

There’s no way around the dairy in homemade Ranch dressing, so if you don’t tolerate milk then another type of dressing will be more your style. But if you do, then the full-fat Greek-style yogurt and cultured buttermilk in this version of Ranch will give you a healthy dose of protein and probiotic cultures every time you spoon it over a bowl of greens. Adding mayonnaise is optional – if you have some on hand and want to add a tablespoon or two you can – but this recipe doesn’t necessarily need it and homemade mayo will change the flavor a bit.

The first time you make the recipe, follow the measurements precisely before altering it. Adding more onion powder or garlic or less dried dill will tip the balance of flavors in a way that strays further from traditional Ranch dressing than you might like. And that secret ingredient? It’s tamari (or soy sauce), which heightens the savory flavor of the dressing much like the questionable MSG does.

Drizzle it over salads, use it as a dip for veggies or meat…go ahead, welcome Ranch dressing back into you life. After trying this all-natural version, you’ll never miss bottled Ranch dressing again.

Ingredients:


  • 1/2 cup full-fat Greek-style yogurt
  • 1/4 cup plus 2 tablespoons cultured buttermilk
  • 2 teaspoons chopped fresh dill
  • 1 heaping teaspoon chopped fresh chives
  • 1/2 teaspoon white wine vinegar
  • 1/4 teaspoon dried dill
  • 1/4 teaspoon kosher salt
  • 1/4 teaspoon tamari
  • 1/8 teaspoon granulated onion powder
  • 1/8 teaspoon black pepper
  • 1/2 of a small garlic clove, finely minced
  • optional: 1-2 tablespoons mayonnaise

 

Instructions:

Simply whisk together all ingredients. The flavors tend to get bolder after a few hours or overnight, so make the dressing ahead of time if possible and refrigerate.


If you'd like to add an avatar to all of your comments click here!

77 thoughts on “Creamy Ranch Dressing”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. how long will this keep? I’m a HUGE ranch fan, this will complete my life. Much thanks! =D

  2. I’ll have to try this – for a dip, I usually just combine equal parts mayo & sour cream with dill, chives, & black pepper, but I must confess that it’s a bit thick for dressing. That salad up top looks fabulous!

    1. I truly hope that people are making the mayo from scratch, otherwise they are totally unaware of the massive load of PUFA they are consuming, nothing primal, paleo or healthy in general about that.

      1. I have made Mayo but I don’t like the idea of using raw eggs. I only make enough for up to 3 days. I hate the commercial Mayo to me it taste so yucky.
        I am looking for a recipe that can be made using heat to sterilize the eggs.

        1. If you find a reliable source of pastured eggs, then raw eggs are incredibly healthy for you.

  3. Full fat yogurt is not available in my area… unless I drive an hour. I can get Fage and Chobani, but they are both low or no fat.
    Looks very good though… I’ll make it with what I have on hand.

    1. You can always make it yourself. We make it here by using a machine. I but the fullest fat milk you can find, your yogurt sample, and full fat cream:) Put in the machine and over several hours you get healthy Greek yogurt.

    2. You can just strain regular full fat yogurt through a cheesecloth-lined strainer until it’s a good consistency.

    3. You could probably use sour cream instead- I buy the brands that list “cultured cream” as the only ingredient. I usually make my ranch dressing with homemade mayo and sour cream but I have done it with yogurt, too, so I think they can pretty much be used interchangeably. I would add extra vinegar or lemon juice if you like it more tangy.

      1. I actually make homeade ranch using the ranch seasoning mix packet and mix it with the “cream” from a can of Thai kitchen coconut milk. Delish and takes about 20 seconds =) This is also my go do recipe for creamy dijon (minus the seasoning mix + a spoonful or two of dijon mustard).

        1. Have you looked at the ingredients in the ranch seasoning packet? This is the Hidden Valley one – Salt, Monosodium Glutamate, Maltodextrin, Dried Garlic, Dried Onion, Parsley, Spice, Carrageenan, Calcium Stearate, Buttermilk.

      1. 1/4 tsp of tamari? Never?

        I happen to think there’s a difference in dose between fermented soy tamari and something like a block of tofu or a bowl of edamame. And as the saying goes: the dose makes the poison.

        Sure, if you have documented zero tolerance for soy, then by all means, eliminate it. But on the spectrum of unhealthy things, a small amount of tamari is hardly a threat.

        1. I tolerate soy just fine, but have eliminated it completely due to all of the different research I’ve read about it. An easy fix if you’re undecided is to sub coconut aminos. Everything I’ve ever used it as a sub for soy for (grammar?) has turned out just lovely. 🙂

  4. This sounds awesome. I’ve never bought buttermilk in my life but if I come across some then I know what I’ll be using it for!

    Ive used the simple oil + vinegar and/or lemon/lime juice with some seasoning dressing mixes for 17 months and it still has not gotten old…

  5. Sounds great! Hmmmm. Twelve ingredients. My ranch recipe will have to do. Sour cream, buttermilk, 1T mayo. Perhaps add a dash of the secret ingredient and a pinch of dill.

  6. Check out The Spunky Coconut today, she has a cashew nut ranch dip recipe. Thicker then this dressing but dairy free.

  7. Wish this had posted two days ago when I was planning my daughter’s birthday party. I’ve got the obligatory veggie platter and I thought Ranch would be awesome with it, but couldn’t find a Primalized version. I ended up making a dip with Greek yogurt, shredded and drained cucumber, dill, garlic, and lemon juice. It’s very good, but it’s no Ranch. 🙂

  8. Hi should stop reading your posts at work. I always get sooo hungry 🙂
    This sounds really great! And the best thing: I just realized I have all the ingredients for it at home, so I’ll give it a try tonight when I’m back from the gym.
    Thanks so much!
    Jen

  9. Ditch mayonnaise (whatever that is) for just 3 boiled egg yolks and it would be perfect.

    Thanks for the recipe, sounds very tasty.

  10. We’re having Mark’s Spicy Chicken and Bacon Poppers (recipe posted on MDA on June 26) tonight and this will make a great dipping sauce for the poppers.

  11. Instead of buying a carton of buttermilk for this, you can stir a tablespoon of vinegar into a cup of regular milk. Let it sit for 5 minutes or so and use like buttermilk.

  12. you still find yourself wishing you had a creamy side to dip your chicken wings in or a rich dressing to pour on your salad

    Which is why I’m waiting for the primal bleu cheese dip recipe.

    1. Primal Blue Cheese dip is easy, I make it all the time!

      1 cup Full fat greek yogurt
      1/4 cup full fat sour cream
      1 tbls lemon juice
      as much blue cheese as you want
      couple dashes of your favourite hot sauce (I use 4-5 dashes of extra hot franks)
      couple pinches of onion powder
      dash or two worchestershire sauce

      Mix it all up and let it sit at least an hour for full flavours to come out and mingle.

  13. Never, never, NEVER liked bottled Ranch dressing (never!). Mom always made it with buttermilk and that is the way the Ranch gods intended Ranch to be made and eaten, by Ranchgum!

    I cannot understand people who like that bottled, shelf-stable crap. It’s nothing like real Ranch dressing!

    Thanks for this! The soy sauce is an intriguing addition, and I can’t wait to give it a whirl.

  14. I am eating this right now on my 2-minute salad, and it is awesome! Thanks for posting.

    1. Guys, the soy he’s recommending is REAL Soy Sauce, which is fermented, and is much healthier than Kikoman or any of those fake crappy versions that have wheat in them. There is a brand called San-J that is completely wheat-free and made the actual way Soy Sauce was designed to be made. Fermented soy in small amounts is okay, and doesn’t have the same negative effects that commercial soy does.

  15. “But honestly, is the odd way that bottled Ranch dressing coats your tongue and the weird, metallic aftertaste something you really, truly miss?”

    Yes, actually. Stop judging me.

  16. I love Ranch Dressing, especially on a grilled chicken salad. Thanks so much for the recipe!!

  17. I love to make my own dressing at home. I think it’s the best way to go, because I never find anything in stores that doesn’t have some kind of preservative in it. I’ve been wanting to look for a recipe for homemade ranch, and not I found it.
    There is just a few spices in there I’ve never heard of, have to check them out. Thanks Mark

    1. Coconut aminos, maybe? I would try to skip it altogether and just add quality salt. If it’s missing something, I would try to tweak and maybe use coconut aminos if you can find it (and afford it!).

      1. Definitely coconut aminos. Stocked on the same shelf as tamari and soy sauce. It’s good stuff, I use it to marinate my beef jerky.

  18. This looks amazing, Mark! I was just thinking about ranch after hittin’ up a salad bar today. I’m DEFINITELY gonna try this, and possibly make a post about it. Looks so good.

  19. Very yummy. I’ll make this one again. I’m always grateful for salad dressing recipes, since the store-bought dressings have bad oils in them and I get tired of olive oil and balsamic every day. I’m currently looking for a good sesame oil/ginger salad dressing – so if anyone has a good one with common ingredients, please post.

    1. This is a good Japanese Ginger Dressing. I think most of the ingredients are Primal enough.

      Japanese Ginger Dressing
      2 tbs peanut oil (or other oil)
      1 tbs toasted sesame oil
      2 tbs rice wine vinegar or white vinegar
      2 tbs minced onion
      1 1/2 tbs grated fresh ginger
      1 tbs sugar free ketchup
      1 tbs tamari
      a little minced garlic
      a little kosher salt
      pepper

      Pour all into a jar with a lid and shake it up.

  20. Mark- what is your opinion on VEGANAISE? You know, Follow Youe Heart? I make my own yummy dipping sauce with it . Yummy!

  21. For those that have made this already, how much does this recipe make? and how long does it keep? I’m putting together the grocery list now, and would like to know.

  22. I’m guessing it will last as long as either the yogurt or buttermilk will, whichever has the earlier expiration date. I was wondering the same thing.

  23. Made this last night. Sons and hubby declared it one of the best things I’ve ever made. First batch completely devoured. Thank you!!

  24. Can anyone tell me, please, what is cultured buttermilk and where can I get it? Thanks.

  25. You can buy cultured buttermilk in any grocery store. It’s near all the other milk products. There’s nothing exotic about it.

  26. I have been making homemade ranch dressing for some time now. I don’t measure, and it comes out almost the same every time. Sour cream, lemon juice, dill, and garlic powder are the most consistent ingredients I use, with salt and pepper to taste. I have never used soy and don’t miss it. I have added chipotle or balsamic vinegar for variations. Also, I love mayo – good, nonprimal like Helman’s. However, I limit it and do not always use it. Plain yogurt works well also. The point is this – experiment with ingredients you have and make just enough for one or two days. This way you don’t waste lots of stuff if it doesn’t come out as tasty as you would like. My husband, who is totally NOT primal, even loves my homemade ranch – that is saying something! He now eats salad up to three nights a week!

  27. Has anyone come up with a substitute for the Good Seasons Italian? I like having the cruet, but when I try my own set of spices I’m off. Any ideas?

  28. God I love ranch but it did scare me how much i craved hidden valley before eliminating most processed foods from my diet! Now I know it’s the msg and additives that I was craving. Soooooo yucky! Can’t wait til I can have dairy again. I will be making this every week!

  29. for the person whose daughter uses red palm oil and bacon grease…I’d luv to have the complete recipe. Thanks

  30. I’ve never been a big fan of dill style ranch dressing, but this is really good! I’ve made it with the Greek yogurt as the recipe calls for, and also with a natural sour cream. Both are good, but I have to say I prefer it made with sour cream. So happy to have a wonderful homemade ranch recipe!

  31. This ranch sounds awesome! Also going to try the ginger dressing another reader posted….
    I do have a question: has anyone attempted a Chipotle restaurant copycat salad dressing. Their dressing is soooo good, but I hear they mostly use soybean oil (not sure about the dressing)
    Thanks!

    1. I’d also like to find a primal copycat recipe for Chipotle restaurant’s salad dressing… Anyone have any ideas?

  32. This creamy ranch dressing is MUCH better using sour cream instead of yogurt. It is less tart, and much smoother. Thanks for the recipe! I will always use it when I want buttermilk ranch dressing.

  33. This is the best homemade ranch! I’ve tried a lot and this one tastes even better than the store bought stuff. Since I don’t keep buttermilk on hand, I sub the same amount of heavy cream and put the vinegar called for (or lemon juice) into it and let it set while I put the rest of the ingredients together. I add more salt (personal preference) and add a little more heavy cream or water if I need it to be thinner.

  34. I also use sour cream instead of yogurt. When I tried yogurt in the past it was much too tart.

  35. Can this be canned? I’d like to make a while big batch of this.

  36. I’m looking for the seasonings to add to the oil to make some ranch flavored sweet potato fries in the oven. I will get some dill and experiment, dump a little of this and a little of than and viola maybe we’ll be creating something fabulous?
    Dill is the thing I think that will make all the goodness happen.

  37. I love your addition of soy sauce, I had never thought of that! I will certainly have to give that a try next time I make a batch of ranch dressing.

  38. I tried making this recipe tonight, and it was really tasty…totally satisfied my ranch cravings. =)

    I did substitute the buttermilk for sour cream as I couldn’t find a source I trusted for the other. It turned out wonderfully, though! Thank you for this.

    1. Er…that is I substituted the buttermilk WITH sour cream. Grammar?

  39. If you’re worried about soy, sub coconut aminos. They taste identical. I have used the 1T vinegar or lemon juice:1c milk as a buttermilk substitute my whole life. It also works with almond milk or heavy cream as well!

  40. Also, try the Julia Child recipe for mayo using liquid coconut oil. I don’t “baby” the ingredients like she recommends n I use an immersion/stick blender. Tastes less than 5 mins n you have a great, neutral tasting mayo that lasts a few weeks in the fridge!

  41. ahhh, the missing ingredients I’ve been looking for, yogurt and soy sauce! Thank you, this is a great substitute for that store bought badness I’m trying to avoid.