Marks Daily Apple
Serving up health and fitness insights (daily, of course) with a side of irreverence.
2 Jun

Vitamin D: Sun Exposure, Supplementation and Doses

From the presence of vitamin D receptors in our cells and vitamin D factories in our epidermis, along with the central role vitamin D plays in calcium metabolism, immunity, and gene expression, it’s pretty clear that having adequate vitamin D is an essential component of being a healthy, successful homo sapien. And yet, many health practitioners suggest that vitamin D deficiency is one of the biggest nutrient deficiencies in modern society. The question, then, arises: What’s the best way to get enough vitamin D – via oral supplementation or sunlight?

To determine that, let’s examine a few common questions surrounding the various modes of intake.

Is it natural?

This is a big one. We obviously care about how nature shaped human evolution. Shouldn’t then our mode of obtaining vitamin D also be “natural”?

For us humans, getting vitamin D from sunlight is the clear winner if judged by this standard alone. We are basically hairless, upright apes for a reason, with hefty D3 requirements, and before oral supplements appeared, dietary vitamin D was not a very reliable source. We had to get it from the sun. Today, we’re still those same hairless, upright apes (albeit with different fashion trends and hygiene sensibilities), and we can still obtain vitamin D from UV-B radiation. Personally, I prefer getting my D3 from sunlight, simply because it’s enjoyable to spend time in the sun and it’s an effortless way to get something that’s critical to my health. But I don’t think it’s necessarily “better” than getting it through supplements. Nature’s way is quite often better, or at least more congruent with how we’re “intended” to work, but that doesn’t always preclude the effectiveness of modern methods.

Additionally, as a little added factoid, this is essentially the way fur-bearing mammals and birds obtain the bulk of their D3: orally. The oils in their fur/feathers produce D3, and preening/self-grooming results in oral intake, with diet rounding out the rest. Skin production is either inadequate or nonexistent. Now, we aren’t dogs or sparrows, but the mechanism for oral intake clearly exists across a wide variation of species.

Yet another question arises: Does oral D3 differ – qualitatively – from solar D3?

Let’s examine the pathways – let’s see what happens when you produce or swallow vitamin D3.

When UV-B reacts with the 7-Dehydrocholesterol in your skin, cholecalciferol (D3) is produced and ends up in your liver, where it’s hydroxilated into calcidiol, also known as 25-hydroxyvitamin D or 25(OH)D.

When you swallow cholecalciferol (either in food or supplement), it ends up in your liver, where it’s hydroxilated into calcidiol, also known as 25-hydroxyvitamin D or 25(OH)D.

From that point onward, it’s all the same. It’s all calcidiol, ready for storage in fat tissue or dispersal to the kidneys for conversion into calcitriol, also known as 1,25(OH)D. Calcitriol is the active hormonal form whose primary role is to regulate blood calcium levels. If there’s enough calcidiol left in the tank after the calcium duties, it gets sent to other tissues in the body to be converted into more calcitriol to fulfill even more roles. That’s where all the immune system/cancer cell/heart health/insulin sensitivity benefits begin to kick in, and it explains why having plenty of vitamin D available – beyond what’s only required to avoid rickets and monitor blood calcium – is so beneficial.

Both oral supplements/dietary sources and sunlight can get you there. Qualitatively, they are identical. The only difference is in the dosage. With oral D3, dosage can be consciously controlled, but it’s also subject to human error (or foolishness). You could conceivably keep popping capsule after capsule and end up with toxic blood levels. It’s difficult to do (one official site suggests the level might be in the millions of IUs), but it’s technically possible. When you sunbathe, on the other hand, you don’t consciously flip a mental switch that shuts down D3 production. Instead, you burn, or you grow uncomfortably hot. You – quite naturally – opt out of sun exposure before it gets too intense. As your skin darkens and you begin to tan, it produces less vitamin D, and you can stay out longer without burning, but it’s generally true that sun exposure up to the brink of turning pink is safe and will net you plenty of D3. In addition, it’s interesting to note that once you have produced enough vitamin D through sun exposure, those same UVB rays will begin to prevent excess vitamin D production by degrading existing cholecalciferol. Ain’t homeostasis grand?

So – sun or supplement? What should I do?

Take stock of your living situation. If the sun is available regularly where you live, go that route whenever possible. It’s free, it’s safe, it’s easy, and it’s enjoyable. Avoid burning, of course, and you’ll be safe. I find it inconceivable that the amount of sun exposure necessary to produce 10,000 IU of D3 (about 20-30 minutes of afternoon sun for light skinned folks; a few times that for dark skinned folks) will also kill you and give you skin cancer.

As with anything, though, ease into the sun. The pasty, mostly interior set will want to treat full sunbathing like learning to barefoot sprint after a lifetime of dress shoes – they’re coming from a position of weakness, of sheltered living. Five minutes of unfiltered rays can turn a freckled redhead lobster-pink, sore, and resigned to indoor living. Just be careful. Ease into things. Learn your limits, and throw on a shirt or find some shade before you burn.

Eating the right foods seems to confer greater natural skin protection against the sun, at least anecdotally. I’m not exactly the best case subject to determine this, as I’ve spent much of my life fairly tan with regular sun exposure, but you hear time and time again about folks who cut the grains, sugar, and industrial vegetable oils, replaced them with veggies, meat, and animal fats, and have never had any issues with the sun again. Nutritional deficiencies do have the tendency to potentiate existing problems or jumpstart/trigger health maladies, so I wouldn’t be surprised. Besides, we’re eating this way regardless. We might as well pick up a few additional theoretical health benefits along the way.

We can’t all bask in the midday sun (if such a thing even exists in our neck of the woods), nor can we even reliably count on there being adequate sunlight on a regular basis. For those of us unable to run shirtless and shoeless through a sun kissed meadow, the last of its residual morning dew having finally evaporated, from noon to 12:45, our option is oral intake.

Certain foods get touted as vitamin D powerhouses: wild salmon, mackerel, herring, cat fish, cod liver oil, eggs. Eat these, but don’t expect to increase your 25(OH)D levels much. Don’t eat the fortified, processed junk which, in the case of cereal grains, actually reduces calcium absorption. It’s a good thing they’re usually fortified with meager amounts of vitamin D, just enough to avoid rickets and keep blood calcium relatively under control. Remember, the body preferentially uses available D for calcium regulation, so it’ll mobilize every last scrap when it comes to matters of the bones – but that is far from optimal. When you eat grains and other junk, you’re increasing your D requirements.

No, food will help, but it won’t suffice. You need something stronger. Might I suggest licking the nearest sunbathing dog? (Would that actually work? I know that most vitamin D3 supplements are isolated and extracted from the fat in lamb’s wool; perhaps a similar concoction could be devised from oily dog fur).

In all seriousness, take a good D3 supplement if you can’t get real sunlight. As long as you don’t go overboard on the dosage, you’re good to go. If it’s not in an oil-based capsule, just take it with a bit of fatty food (not a stretch for an Primal eater). It travels the same pathway and results in the same benefits. It’s always easier to just let nature take its course, but it’s not always realistic.

A good general rule is 4000 IU per day supplemented. That’s what I take during winter time and when I go a few days trapped indoors and without sun (as I was last weekend while at the Book Expo of America in New York). Get your 25(OH)D levels tested before you start supplementation, take the 4k IU daily, and get them tested again after two months. Aim to get your levels up around 50-60 ng/mL, which is where most of the big benefits seem to kick in. If you don’t respond well to 4000 IU, feel free to increase the dosage. Given that we can make around 10,000 IU in well under an hour, supplementation up to that level is well tolerated.

I’ll end it here for now, with more coming tomorrow. It’s a big topic and there’s a lot to cover.

You want comments? We got comments:

Imagine you’re George Clooney. Take a moment to admire your grooming and wit. Okay, now imagine someone walks up to you and asks, “What’s your name?” You say, “I’m George Clooney.” Or maybe you say, “I’m the Clooninator!” You don’t say “I’m George of George Clooney Sells Movies Blog” and you certainly don’t say, “I’m Clooney Weight Loss Plan”. So while spam is technically meat, it ain’t anywhere near Primal. Please nickname yourself something your friends would call you.

  1. nice post man.. keep post

    john wrote on December 22nd, 2011
  2. I enjoy you because of Thank you for all of the every one of your effort hard work on this site.

    gorge smith wrote on December 26th, 2011
  3. You have mentioned very interesting points! ps nice website.
    I like this web blog very much, Its a very nice billet to read and get info.

    Camisa wrote on January 2nd, 2012
  4. Vitamin D is good to our body and increase immunity system i learn a lot of your article thanks for sharing it.

    Taxi Zürich wrote on January 31st, 2012
  5. Nice post, thank you!

    sudo wrote on February 17th, 2012
  6. Wonderful! I will be coming back to your blog for more soon….
    Everybody likes free music right? I found a way to get Free iTunes Redeem Codes legally which only takes a few mins.

    free-itunes-redeem-codes wrote on February 22nd, 2012
  7. good article,
    it’d been given new knowledge for me.

    Free Internet and Indonesian Lawa wrote on February 22nd, 2012
  8. thanks you very much , post very important for me
    thanks a gain!

    Jameuk wrote on February 22nd, 2012
  9. This is a excellent blog, will you be involved in doing an interview about just how you created it? If so e-mail me!

    Mary List wrote on March 11th, 2012
  10. Nice topic related to Sun it really give Vitamin D.

    top b schools in india wrote on March 14th, 2012
  11. your blog is very unique, im very enjoy in your blog

    KuPas wrote on April 4th, 2012
  12. Thanks qualia for the note about sensitivity to D3 Supplements The first time I ever experienced angina was after my doctor prescribed the 50K IU vit D capsules 2x times a week. (I was at 11.8 ng! in March 08) I can tolerate the 400 IU’s that are in the kids multivitamins and try to keep up the gardening! I’m rocking at 31 and my new PCM is still on me for an upward trend or he’s putting me on supplements. I’m not perfectly primal, but everything is better when I stick to the plan!

    Read more:

    Melisa wrote on April 16th, 2012
  13. Vitamin D is very important to functionality of body, specially you can get vitamin D from sunlight in early morning.

    Escort Paris wrote on May 3rd, 2012
  14. Excellent Content.It is very Helpfull.How to make money from online surveys.Free registration.No need To pay any penny at least.

    Lifespeed free surveys wrote on June 5th, 2012
  15. Excellent Content.Very nice niche.Free online Surveys.Give your option and make money from online surveys.Earn free money.Fee Signup.

    Lifespeed free surveys wrote on June 5th, 2012
  16. I was very happy to uncover this page. I wanted to thank you for your time for this particularly fantastic read!! I definitely liked every little bit of it and i also have you saved as a favorite to see new information in your web site.

    Zoloft Birth Defects Blog wrote on June 6th, 2012
  17. Thats why i love hiking in the morning and expose to the sun so that i can get more vitamins thanks for the helpful information.

    Phollaine wrote on September 6th, 2012
  18. I have noticed my dog lying in the hot sun sometimes and he looks very content. I think it’s too hot for him and call him in and he’s reluctant to leave his sunny spot. Now, I’ll let him stay as long as he wants. I was wondering if the dog and cats sunning was a healthy thing like it is for me.

    Thanks Mar, for all your work.

    W.J. Purifoy wrote on September 16th, 2012
  19. Interesting product here:

    Anyone tried anything similar?

    Amanda wrote on February 28th, 2013
  20. I know I’m way late, but is it possible that we need those times of the year when we don’t get much sun due to temperatures? It just seems that we adapted to live on the planet with periods of time where there is little to no sunlight.

    Dalton K. wrote on May 9th, 2013
  21. Hi Mark,

    I am so glad I found your site, thank you for all the great reading material. I just did a Vitamin D level blood test for the first time – and it is 5! My doc put me on 50,000 UI once per week but he gave me Vitamin D2 not D3. I am not sure why and read on other sites that you need to take Vitamin D3 NOT Vitamin D2. Of course, my Doctor is off on vacation and I was wondering what your take on this is. I am young, healthy, I do sports and actually spend at least 25 to 30 min outside running around, even though I live in NYC. Many thanks!

    Nina wrote on July 31st, 2013
  22. The ultraviolet light in sunlight is ionizing radiation, which directly mutates DNA – that’s how it causes cancer. Humans are not all that well optimized to deal with cancer in our old age because over our evolutionary lifespan, we were much more likely to be killed by an infection or predator than we currently are. If you plan to die at 35, I wouldn’t worry about the cancer risk of sunlight, but if you intend on living into your 60s or 70s or later, then cumulative sunlight exposure should be a concern.

    Given the tremendously better availability of healthy foods in modern times, most people now can get sufficient vitamin D from their diet, and if that works for you, there is no downside to doing that. There is certainly a strong upside to eating your leafy vegetables. Whether or not it makes anyone any money, getting vitamin D from diet or supplements is certainly safer, regardless of whether or not it’s more “natural”. Advising people that sunlight is the safest way to get vitamin D is clearly wrong and potentially quite harmful!

    Christopher Beland wrote on September 29th, 2013
  23. I live in Dallas, Texas. I’m curious to know if I can get enough Vitamin D from the sun exposure during the winter months here in Dallas ( Nov – March)
    My level is at 24 right now and I’m pregnant. I am taking 2000 IU D3 supplements daily. will that be enough?

    Vani wrote on November 12th, 2013
  24. Mark, my vitamin D3 fish oil capsuke contains saflower oil. I take 1,000 Iu’s per day. Is it safe to keep takin with safflower oil?

    Anne P wrote on November 29th, 2013
  25. I’m surprised that this article didn’t touch on the role that melanin plays in the production of vitamin D in the body. The more melanin someone has, the less vitamin D their body is going to produce because melanin protects the skin against ultra violet light. The darker your skin, the longer you would have to stay in the sun to produce vitamin D. That includes those donning temporary tans. Therefore, it is advisable to get quality vitamin D through the diet with fatty fish, liver, eggs and cod liver oil. Twenty minutes of sun exposure is too much for a fair skinned person; only a few minutes of sunbathing is needed for the body to begin making vitamin D because it is directly related to the amount of melanin.

    Ty wrote on December 28th, 2013
  26. I’m taking 50000 ui vit. D. I’ve also been. In the sun due to sudden weather changes mid 60 and 70 degree temps. I have been sick off and on for at least a week. Today is the worst. Nauseated vomiting some and abdomina
    Pain. Wondering if I’m getting toxic. I take one per week for 7 weeks and am almost done. I was at a 18 on my blood test. Any comments?

    mjay wrote on February 20th, 2014
  27. Dear mark,

    It has taken a year starting with 30 to get to 49 for me! I am taking vit D3 2000 to 5000 according to sun exposure availability. I am also completely primal!
    I have recently read Wheat Belly and there is a recommendation for shiratki noodles made with some kind of vegetable root with potato starch and calcium hydroxy. That doesn’t sound primal to me! Anyone who has tried them here?

    Jean finch wrote on March 7th, 2014
  28. If one has sun allergy, is it possible to get necessary dose od vitamin D with supplements and food? or is there any other source to keep vitamized?

    Maya wrote on May 3rd, 2014
  29. Wow…talk about an eye opener! My bottle of Vit D is 400iu. I actually had to go get the bottle as surely I must have misread it.

    You’d mentioned at the end of the post “…if you don’t respond well to 4000iu, feel free to increase”. Im assuming the only way to tell how you are responding is through lab work, correct? If I bump my 400iu to 4000iu…I wont physically be noticing any difference?

    GREAT article…thank you!

    Brenda S wrote on July 10th, 2014

Leave a Reply

If you'd like to add an avatar to all of your comments click here!

© 2015 Mark's Daily Apple

Subscribe to the Newsletter and Get a Free Copy
of Mark Sisson's Fitness eBook and more!