Yes, exactly. Also, Taubes documents something that I have personally lived through. The mass changing of the American diet. I remember back in the 70s if you ordered the diet plate it was a hamburger patty, cottage cheese and a melon wedge. Everybody else ate chicken and dumplings, turkey with gravy sandwiches and mashed potatoes with real butter, or steak and potatoes. When mom made cookies she used real butter or crisco. We often had bacon and eggs, pot roast on Sunday, sometimes even steak. I believe at one point steak was cheaper than chicken. Good mid-western cuisine dripping in butter and lard or crisco (crisco made things lighter and flakier so that's why we used it.)
Originally Posted by KimchiNinja
Then in 1980 they said that lard and butter and steak and eggs were bad for you and would give you heart disease. They also told us they made you fat. So now the diet plate became pasta primavera. We all stopped eating steak and switched to pasta and bread. We bought fat-free cheese, fat-free cookies, baked potato chips. Everybody who said all the junk food is equally fat to carb wasn't there in the 80s. Fat-free sour cream, fat-free salad dressing, Pam to spray your pan so you didn't use any fat to cook with. The ratio of carbs to fat in the diet changed hugely and the protein went down since meat was going to kill you (only eat one serving the size of a pack of playing cards, blah blah blah.)
I'm now old enough to have grand-children. What I think happened is such a fat-free diet messed up the delicate balance of hormones and set off mutagenic or teratogenic processes. The children today are getting diabetes II in childhood now. The people today who are obese gave up on fat-free everything and just said screw it. They are the ones who are doing the high crap fat, high crap sugar to excess, but they were probably also born broken, making it worse. Meanwhile, food is very expensive and our salaries are worse than they were in the 70s so to hide the fact that we actually can't afford good food anymore, there are subsidies and other structures both formal and informal in place to make food cheaper by filling it with crap fillers and cheap processed commodity ingredients. Turkeys injected with fake butter and brine seem juicy and good for thanksgiving. Spaghetti sauce in a jar with a significant portion of the calories replaced with corn syrup seems like a good value. Heck, even black pepper cut with sugar is $2 cheaper than real black pepper. So now, even people who are trying to be decent and healthy have fewer options for healthy ingredients and even thin and relatively healthy people are getting diabetes and struggling to keep the weight off once they hit 40.
But you (charlii) can go ahead and pretend that none of this happened and continue your bizarre fight against two people who speak more eloquently and learnedly than you, people who have actually done research and helped people. And for what purpose, I don't know. I wonder what you get out of it? Some kind of feeling of superiority? It's a train wreck to watch you writhe and froth at the mouth around here.
Exactly. I went backpacking with a Japanese man. His wife made him bring healthy foods on the trip. He really just wanted to taste all the great American junk food. What do Americans usually bring backpacking? Mac-and-cheese, Mountain House, granola, peanuts etc. What do Japanese? Dried steamed brown rice, seaweed, natto, chicken, pork and beef, dried green veggies and carrots.
Originally Posted by KimchiNinja
The people who are lean are not saying "fuck it" because they weren't born damaged by 3 generations of low-fat, cholesterol will kill you, meat will kill you messaging. They probably prioritize meat, even processed meat, over pastries when they shop. The ones who are trying really hard to be healthy are eating vegetarian or eating tiny amounts of meat and not getting enough protein. They're afraid of cholesterol so they aren't getting the building blocks of sex hormones and are getting fertility treatments and little blue pills. Some diet and exercise themselves to extremes. The lucky ones probably had grandmas and moms who kept on cooking with lard, butter and crisco, who kept serving pot roast for dinner and pork chops. Or beans with a ham hock or whatever. The sick and obese said fuck it long ago and just eat whatever tastes good.
Originally Posted by charlii
Female, 5'3", 50, Starting weight: 163lbs. Current weight: 135 (more or less).
I can squat 187.5lbs, press 75lbs and deadlift 200lbs