First off, chuck the scale. Or I should say, reframe your goal. Do you want to be thinner (in inches)? Or do you want to hit a specific scale weight? Or a specific body weight? While all are body comp goals, they aren't necessarily the same thing.
How long have you been doing 5x5? Since even at +5# on squat a workout, it adds up very fast. What are your numbers on the deadlift? What other activity do you do? Any cardio or walking on the other days?
And since you offered, sure, throw some pics up.