I'd just like to endorse pklopp's writing. I eat one meal a day because it's the only sustainable form of calorie restriction I've ever encountered. If I ever eat food before 4:00 PM, it literally ruins my day. I know it's silly to think of it in black and white terms like that, but past experience dictates that this is true for me.
I normally follow leangains, so on training days (3-4x/week) I eat a 2,200-2,300 calorie meal at roughly 7:00 PM and on rest days I eat a 1,700 calorie meal at that same time. I don't count calories anymore, but I'm an excellent guesser based on years of counting calories. I do still weigh my foods though.
*Ok so I gotta eat what grok ate?: cut out grains and seed oils, limit dairy and avoid legumes, OK got it.
*Move like grok you say aswell?: plenty of low intensity movement, some heavy lifting and an occasional sprint, too easy.
*So you say grok got plenty of sleep, sun and play also, well that's not so hard.
*"woohoo Im fully primal" they might say
So a few months later they're back on the forums, because they've hit a stall or some other problem and everybody is telling them "up your daily carbs a little", "restrict your cals a bit more, CICO rules ok", "macros at 50/20/30 for you" "you aren't lifting heavy enough", "hows your sleep", I could go on.
Most are missing a very important factor of TPB, one just as important as what to eat....
HOW DO I EAT? and more importantly, HOW DID GROK EAT? I found great success (lost 60 pounds in 4 months) by asking myself those few additional questions at the start of my primal journey (check out the post in my sig for more on this).
well done mikegee2 for contemplating those same questions.
A little primal gem - My Success Story
Weight lost in 4 months - 29kg (64 lbs)
Really interesting thread.
I think my single biggest factor to my weight and fat loss was something so simple as dropping breakfast. I haven't had breakfast for nearly 18 months and I don't miss it.
I think it is all about finding a routine which works for you.
My current structure is a 7-8 hour eating window (which is really just lunch and dinner) and 2 x 24 hr fasts a week.
I am considering doing the one meal thing but I work at a desk and I enjoy my big ass salads too much I think but I may trial it at some stage.
2010 - 5,11 and 101KG
2012 - 5,11 and 77KG
Train hard, eat well and love life
Thanks to all...I am about 20 lbs over my "Actuarial weight", and I never listen to my wife...I'm a guy. I just began to watch her eat out of curiosity. I would say" eye of round and a little braised greens tonight..want some? and she would say nah..I had a big lunch today, still full".....And I started seeing that I ate out of habit the old dr. Pepper thing 10-2-4 no matter what. I watched all the lions on TV get almost distended with meat, their instincts knowing the next meal could be missed or stolen.
but I work all day. If I ate till I was satiated or over that I'd never see a patient all day. I'd be asleep. So I asked myself..If Grok ate what he killed and then hunted again knowing he might not eat tomorrow, then where is the median place? My CRON wife has eaten when she is hungry only for years. She says she never eats till she is satiated. So there must be something to not eating till satiation. Imo, This is extremely hard to do when you are on a "fixed" three meals a day schedule. This intermittent fasting looks interesting and I am reading the thread. I eat fairly low carb because I feel, like the person who said this here" I like veggies, I just don't feel obligated to them.
There is great stuff here to think about...This am I ate 3eggs and some bacon and a half an apple ...at 9:00. My wife just asked where will we eat today? I can't think about food, but if i went with her, I know I would eat. Is that just poor impulse control? I don't think so. But I don't know what it is other than habit. Fixing this will be tougher than fixing what I eat.
thanks for helping me to figure it out
I often think about that predatory instinct. For me, the notion of sitting down to eat but stopping short of fullness is the most demoralizing, cruel, unlivable thing ever. When people discuss 5-6 mini-meal plans it sounds like a vision of hell.
So I don't do it. Unfortunately my stomach could probably handle 3+ feasts a day but I know I only need 1 so I eat 1, and it tastes better with the mild appetite. Eating ~10 times a week might be seriously alarming to other people but I figure most people who eat poorly are conforming to modern culture so maybe we need to discard some of that.
Whenever I eat breakfast or brunch, I'm hungry for the rest of the day. I've tried three meals a day and it made me fat. When the recommendation became "grazing" or 4-6 meals a day, I just laughed. I like a big meal. Right weight or skinny or fat, I can eat like a male construction worker. If I did this three times a day, I'd weigh as much also - not good for a five foot five female. What I do is plan my eating just like any other to-do list. I plan my big meal (supper), and plan coffee or snacks around that. I get 50%+ of my calories from my main meal. It sounds hard, but it really isn't. It's just a matter of habit. Do it for six weeks, and bam! - it's a habit.
"Right is right, even if no one is doing it; wrong is wrong, even if everyone is doing it." - St. Augustine
I do think fasting is good for me and I like the way it makes me feel. I'm not interested in craving it the way I used to crave food, so I'm not dogmatic about any kind of schedule. I skip breakfast and sometimes lunch on the weekends. I skip breakfast once or twice a week during the work week and have a small late breakfast and a small late lunch the other days. I have come to really dislike the feeling of being stuffed, so dinner is rarely more than 1200 calories and often less. At an average of 1700 cal/day, I'm still slowly losing weight without feeling like I'm depriving myself. That feels really nice. I may try longer than 20 hr fasts at some point. I don't know. Right now I'm just enjoying being at a normal weight, eating a normal amount of food and feeling no stress over any of it. I keep thinking "this is what thin people feel like their whole lives!"
CW-125, part calorie counting, part transition to primal
GW- Goals are no longer weight-related