Yes, carbs DRIVE hunger. Watch out.
serenity, I also can feel hungry from too much fat. Now that could be because I'm still losing weight, and I eat fewer calories than some folks. Which means that a lot of any one macro makes it tough to eat other foods (especially fat at 9 cal per gram). When I tried to go from about 50-60% calories from fat (mostly 50%) up to 70%, I just got hungry the same way I would if I suddenly started living on pasta and cereal.
At one end of the spectrum is CW: 60% cal from carbs, low fat everything. At the other is HFLC: up to 70% cal from fat, as few carbs as possible. Another continuum is frequency. At one end is grazing, at the other is IF. It takes a bit of time to see which point on the spectrum ultimately works for you. It's not and either-or kind of thing. You don't have to be CW or HFLC - there are an almost infinite number of points on that curve, and one is right for you.
"Right is right, even if no one is doing it; wrong is wrong, even if everyone is doing it." - St. Augustine
Yes, carbs DRIVE hunger. Watch out.
I love this post. It's so positive.
I think part of the problem is when you think it has to be extreme. If some fat is good, more is better. If less carbs is good, even less is better. And I don't think it works that way, and I don't think the plan is written that way. I did Atkins. I tried lowering carbs to less than 10 percent of calories, and fat over 70. I was hungry (partly from artificial sweeteners, sure, but it wasn't just that). I raised the carbs up to the 50-100 grams (total) level, and my calories magically dropped about 400kc a day. Because the extra fiber filled me up? Because I need nutrients in the veggies that I wasn't getting before? I don't know, but it worked. Appetite controlled, cravings better. Then I dropped the diet coke and the calories dropped another 400kc per day, give or take. Crazy.
So yeah, when I say limiting carb heavy food I don't mean eliminating carbs, or just eating meat. I mean a plate 2/3 filled with veggies and 1/3 a piece of meat with some fat on it. I stopped worrying if I was getting too many carrots (really a silly thought) and just avoid the grains, limit nuts and dairy, and go with it. I haven't started sweet potatoes yet, but am not worried...I'll limit them until I reach my goal.
So often people take it to extremes...it isn't natural to eat extremely low fat (just eating chicken breasts every day) but it isn't natural to ONLY eat fat either, for the most part. Think of eating the whole animal...some days will be dark meat, some will be white, some lean cuts, some fatty cuts. Eating just pats and pats of butter probably won't solve any issues and yes will up your calories.
About the same. ~ 2 hrs dedicated movement (right now the WOD + walking, swimming or elliptical) plus standing in the office at my station and playing.Looks like a healthy balance to me. Your protein and fat is more than adequate for a small woman such as yourself. Still not a high carb diet, relatively speaking. I have 200-250g most days. Not sure what your activity is like, but I'm fairly active with exercise these days (2h/day).
I have to emphasize that I am hungry on this. The nature of my hunger changes with macros: shaky-dizzy on high carb/low fat to lethargic on VLC. Right now it is in between. Hunger is always there. If I eat >1700 cals, hunger is low, but I gain, if I eat <1500, I lose a little, but end up very hungry in 3 to 4 days. If I try to 'stagger' calories and macros or IF for longer than 14-15 hours, I end up binging and can't stop eating.
My Journal: http://www.marksdailyapple.com/forum/thread57916.html
When I let go of what I am, I become what I might be.
Of course calories consumed and burnedmatter, there is no body fat fairie that makes it mysteriously appear or disappear. But eating good, primal food is the key to eating less (and, feeling better and more energetic so you can burn more!)
"...You sort of start thinking anything's possible if you've got enough nerve. -Ginny
My story: http://www.marksdailyapple.com/i-now...#axzz2MzPtxo00
The carb curve works like a charm for me. And thats all I got to say about that.