this thread started out with me saying '.....what?'
and has ended with sadness
gorbag, here is my opinion, put succinctly; it's a bad idea.
you cannot round up a group of people and lock them in a cage, guarded by men with guns. it's a Bad Thing.
history will tell you it's a Bad Thing
any action that begins with a declaration of 'it's for your own good' is generally a Bad Thing