I think I have the same problem as you - its not splatter!! I can wipe and wipe till the cows come home and the paper is always brown...

Not every time I go but a lot. I think we are not getting it all out and there is some fecal matter still sitting there needing to be expressed but short of bursting some veins by pressing it doesn't want to come. Maybe the consistency? At those times it seems quite gluey. Probably need more veggie matter to bulk it up. I know when I drink green smoothies my feces are bulkier and not...gluey... for lack of a better word. Is this your problem?