Originally Posted by Kilian
Originally Posted by InSearchOfAbs
Sorry, not a hater, but I am mystified. As pklopp was doing and logging changes and trying to see how it works etc. I think is a good effort at least to try to understand what is going on with it. I even somewhat understand the concept of using potatoes as a "hack" (as it has been called - even though I couldn't do it), but I am not understanding calling it a "diet" (in the common understanding of the word) since that is what paleo/primal are so not about at all. And I think it is telling that when someone comes along and says that in their opinion eating plain potatoes would be boring (in their opinion mind you) that the wagons are circled.
Originally Posted by BratKat
I also happen to think that it is important to make comments for the sake of those who are new to paleo/primal. It's good for them to understand as they are learning about the ins and outs of making dietary changes that just because there are a number of threads dedicated to "taters" that there are also paleo/primal eaters who don't agree, or can't understand that kind of "hack," or are interested in the science behind it before they would actually do it.
Respectfully, this is also a public forum and so I think it should be an expectation to have comments from people who might not agree with you. If you want to have a forum that is private you will have to start your own I think. There are blogs that allow you to set up and keep it private...
Female, age 51, 5' 9"
SW - 183 (Jan 22, 2012), CW - 159, GW - healthy.
Met my 2012 goals by losing 24 pounds.
2013 goals are to get fit and strong!