Why do you want to be a raw vegan?
...lasted 20 min, between me opening a jar of hemp protein, putting the numbers through the Fit Day and realizing that there is no way I can live even a day on 5 smoothies with this ingredient & NOTHING else. I love a smoothie once in a while, but I am still in shock. And here I thought ketonic was extreme. (Sigh). Here goes my dream of a sweet day of raw fruit and veggies. The reality was pretty bad. It's not just smoothies, it's awful tasting smoothies, because the taste is crap. I can do one a day on a carb-up day since the nutritional profile is stellar, but that's about it. I guess, I have a screw lose somewhere, I just can't seem to adhere to strict diets at all. I always want everything.
Why do you want to be a raw vegan?
I don't know if Zoe Harcombe is respected/ignored/vilified here, but in the post Five a day: The truth , she compares combinations of 5 foods you'd need to get RDAs as an omnivore, vegetarian, and vegan.
I understand this is just one person's opinion, and the parameters she set were artificial because of course we all have more than five foods available to us. But I found it interesting that with the veganism, you'd not only have to add oil to your diet, but you'd have to take a supplement. Over and over again in my reading, when I was trying to figure out how to change my diet to a healthy one, I found that veganism comes with a need for supplementation.After all this, is there a perfect five-a-day? I set about doing what should have been done before any of this started. I went back to the USDA nutrition database and tried to get the Recommended Dietary Allowances (RDAs) from just five foods. This can be achieved with 100 grams of liver, 200 grams of sardines, 200 grams of whole milk, 100 grams of sunflower seeds and 200 grams of broccoli (1,300 calories). There will be infinite combinations of real foods that can provide the RDAs, but I started from the ones known to be highly nutritious.
For interest, I repeated the experiment for a vegetarian diet and the biggest challenge became vitamin D. The RDAs could be met with five foods: 500 grams of whole milk, 450 grams of eggs (10 medium eggs), 300 grams of spinach, 250 grams of raw mushrooms grown in sunshine and 50 grams of sunflower seeds (1,360 calories). Dietary advisors applaud people for choosing a vegetarian diet, but then tell them to avoid eggs and to consume low-fat milk. It then becomes practically impossible for a vegetarian to meet even minimal nutritional requirements. I had returned to eating meat and fish before the research for this part of the book, but, this exercise gave me great concern about what lasting damage I may have done to my health during years of not eating meat and fish. Gwyneth Paltrow may also be re-evaluating her diet after sharing her medical experience on her health website (June 2010). Paltrow’s vitamin D levels were tested by doctors in New York, following a “pretty severe” bone fracture and they “turned out to be the lowest they had ever seen.”[viii]
Vegans can’t get B12 naturally and they would need to eat 2.25 kilograms of (raw sunshine grown) mushrooms in a fat delivery mechanism (e.g. vegetable oil) to get the ‘adequate intake’ for vitamin D and an unusual food like oriental dried radishes to get their calcium – and to repeat this daily. For completeness, the five vegan foods would be 2.25 kilograms of mushrooms, 175 grams of porridge oats, 25 grams of sunflower seeds, 100 grams of oriental dried radishes and 300 grams of spinach (in more vegetable oil) and a vitamin B12 supplement. Without the calories in the vegetable oil, the vegan basket adds up to 1,644 calories – the highest of all three sample ways of getting our nutritional requirement.
Nothing wrong with raw fruits and veggies of course. They're delicious and healthy. They're just not the whole story.
My cousin just went raw vegan. I told her to come talk to me when she's sick of feeling soft, sluggish and angry.
I'm all for raw foods, but I don't think I could ever be vegan. Power to ya though! Instead of hemp protein, try Sun Warrior Warrior Blend. The texture is not the best, but it tastes okay and is primal friendly for the most part (it's got some pea protein, but I think you could do a lot worse)
I have an issues with high fat diet being very hard to control calorically & having to stick to ketosis all week when the best I can fit in is some cabbage and celery, then a clean carb-up on potatoes, so that's like a beautiful dream of a day when I can eat things I actually like... fruit, mainly. I miss fruit the most during the week. Plus, meats are so hard - they are good, but you can only eat a tiny bit volumetrically, and the more fat, the less you can eat (and the best meats are fatty); and if you have carb cap, you can't make up volume from veggies (unless you like really go wild on spinach).
But, I have problem with caloric controls as soon as I start eating my fruit (people who say that it's hard to get enough calories on a vegetarian diet haven't seen me devouring buckets of fruit), so I thought I can limit it if I stick to Raw Vegan. But it just doesn't pan out, as yeah, I practically have to do meal replacement instead of my dream day of eating everything I want with a pinch of protein powder to get my 100 g protein. So, yeah, I am better off with egg whites and Greek yogurt as the source, and the rest from fruit/veg. It limits the amount of fruit I can eat, of course, but yeah, tough luck.
I am perfectly fine with just veggies and fruit all day for a day, but one look at my protein count and it's not gonna happen! I need 100 g min, and 150 ideal.
Last edited by Leida; 11-05-2012 at 11:47 AM.
And thank you, Dr.Bork Bork, the prot/calories of the SWW blend is far better than raw hemp.
But I am also considering which part is more important to me: Raw or Vegan? Because if I commit to just Raw, I can do some raw meat, fish and eggs, no pro; if I commit to just vegan, here come the beans to the rescue... But on the whole, I am wondering if I just lack the screw, or commitment, or conviction, or something... it just sounds like some sort of a game, rather than the real thing somehow.
Last edited by Leida; 11-05-2012 at 11:52 AM.
If you do go raw vegan, you are going to have to hand in your Primal Club Card.
I Kettlebell therefore I am.
Seriously, maybe you lack common sense. I know your goal is to have a muscular yet lean body. Veganism....does not seem likely to accomplish that.But on the whole, I am wondering if I just lack the screw, or commitment, or conviction, or something... it just sounds like some sort of a game, rather than the real thing somehow.
I know this is so fucking cheesy, but your issue doesn't seem to be food mix, but rather self control (ie, you feel you overeat certain foods). What about trying something like "Deal a Meal" or Weight Watchers, only stick to whole primal foods, but with boundaries on how much you can eat?
One thing I am realizing.... there will always be a food I will overeat if I let myself. Whole 30- it was dates.... Primal, it's dark chocolate, paleo- a love for the coconut milk. Eliminating foods doesn't do a damn thing to fix the problem.
I know you have a really high goal for yourself, and you are willing to sacrifice a lot to get there... but are you sure you want to sacrifice health..... especially when you consider that you could potentially look worse as a end result of veganism?