Page 4 of 8 FirstFirst ... 23456 ... LastLast
Results 31 to 40 of 72

Thread: Is Paleo nothing more than Atkins Diet reborn ???? page 4

  1. #31
    BennettC's Avatar
    BennettC is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2012
    Location
    Beaufot, SC
    Posts
    528
    Primal Fuel
    Call me what you want, I really don't give a shit. The inuit had perfect health because they lived on meat, zero carbs. No disease, no carries, perfect teeth, ect, ect, ect. I don't eat a zero carb diet but I think its good model. And this isn't "my way". I didn't just make up this diet. I think we are all way healthier than the average American. I think better health can be achieve by avoiding processed foods, grains, and sugars. But there is good, better, and best. Hell you eat rice, what does your opinion matter anyways. I thought this was supposed to be a paleo diet forum
    Paleo since November 2011 - Carnivore since June 2012
    Before and after pics
    http://www.marksdailyapple.com/forum/thread65846.html
    Primal Sucess Story
    http://www.marksdailyapple.com/forum/thread65400.html
    Primal Journal
    http://www.marksdailyapple.com/forum...tml#post955444

  2. #32
    magnolia1973's Avatar
    magnolia1973 is online now Senior Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Posts
    3,909
    Bennett, careful trusting too much in science. You can find science to prove anything. When I was a vegan, damn straight I had all the science that let me know how bad meat was and how it ages us. Repeat for low fat etc. etc. etc. Science is great to a point....

    It's their life, but for you to go out and tell them that maybe they should eat some more carbohydrates for weight loss is absolutely ridiculous.
    This is a situation I see all the time on here "I'm not losing weight, I ate 20 grams of carbs yesterday and am just feeling like shit, this isn't working". If that person doesn't eat more carbs (good PRIMAL carbs), they run a real likelihood of abandoning the whole primal thing altogether. Science is one thing, but human nature is another and why primal works for so many people is that handy 20% clause which allows use some bad along with a whole lot of good.

    It's irresponsible to encourage people to eat in a way that they are miserable and is not sustainable, when the addition of healthy foods would give them an equally healthy diet that they can sustain on. I'm doing Whole 30 right now, and let me tell you, a banana has kept me from plunging headfirst into the Haagen Daz. Carbs, yep.....

    I do believe some people do great on low carb and it must be a god send. But for many of us the addition of some carbs is a god send, and probably not that far off of this "elusive" optimal diet anyway.

  3. #33
    BennettC's Avatar
    BennettC is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2012
    Location
    Beaufot, SC
    Posts
    528
    Quote Originally Posted by magnolia1973 View Post
    Bennett, careful trusting too much in science. You can find science to prove anything. When I was a vegan, damn straight I had all the science that let me know how bad meat was and how it ages us. Repeat for low fat etc. etc. etc. Science is great to a point....



    This is a situation I see all the time on here "I'm not losing weight, I ate 20 grams of carbs yesterday and am just feeling like shit, this isn't working". If that person doesn't eat more carbs (good PRIMAL carbs), they run a real likelihood of abandoning the whole primal thing altogether. Science is one thing, but human nature is another and why primal works for so many people is that handy 20% clause which allows use some bad along with a whole lot of good.

    It's irresponsible to encourage people to eat in a way that they are miserable and is not sustainable, when the addition of healthy foods would give them an equally healthy diet that they can sustain on. I'm doing Whole 30 right now, and let me tell you, a banana has kept me from plunging headfirst into the Haagen Daz. Carbs, yep.....

    I do believe some people do great on low carb and it must be a god send. But for many of us the addition of some carbs is a god send, and probably not that far off of this "elusive" optimal diet anyway.
    I totally agree with everything you said. And I apologize to everyone for coming off the way I just have. I'm young and I have a temper, I have no problem admitting to that. This has taught me a lot as I really would like to do something in nutrition and you have to handle different people different ways. I was eating a high carb diet when I started paleo and I still felt great, I feel better now. But as I previously said any given person on this forum is in better health than the standard American on a SAD diet. Just watched my mother eat a bowl of ramen and gingerbread cookie for lunch.
    Paleo since November 2011 - Carnivore since June 2012
    Before and after pics
    http://www.marksdailyapple.com/forum/thread65846.html
    Primal Sucess Story
    http://www.marksdailyapple.com/forum/thread65400.html
    Primal Journal
    http://www.marksdailyapple.com/forum...tml#post955444

  4. #34
    Owly's Avatar
    Owly is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    3,823
    Oh noes, I eat rice! A lot of paleo folks do things like that, or they drink beer, or whatever. Mark Sisson sometimes puts sugar in coffee. It's not a purity test.

    The Inuit had good health. So did many other peoples who ate carbs.

    If science had proven conclusively what produced ideal health, then it would be simple. Even the paleo experts don't agree on what's ideal (see Robb Wolf's take on dairy or on carbs versus Mark Sisson's, for example).
    “If I didn't define myself for myself, I would be crunched into other people's fantasies for me and eaten alive.” --Audre Lorde

    Owly's Journal

  5. #35
    BennettC's Avatar
    BennettC is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2012
    Location
    Beaufot, SC
    Posts
    528
    Quote Originally Posted by Owly View Post
    Oh noes, I eat rice! A lot of paleo folks do things like that, or they drink beer, or whatever. Mark Sisson sometimes puts sugar in coffee. It's not a purity test.

    The Inuit had good health. So did many other peoples who ate carbs.

    If science had proven conclusively what produced ideal health, then it would be simple. Even the paleo experts don't agree on what's ideal (see Robb Wolf's take on dairy or on carbs versus Mark Sisson's, for example).
    agreed. sorry for getting so defensive, in fact I had a beer yesterday lol
    Paleo since November 2011 - Carnivore since June 2012
    Before and after pics
    http://www.marksdailyapple.com/forum/thread65846.html
    Primal Sucess Story
    http://www.marksdailyapple.com/forum/thread65400.html
    Primal Journal
    http://www.marksdailyapple.com/forum...tml#post955444

  6. #36
    Lewis's Avatar
    Lewis is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Posts
    2,344
    Quote Originally Posted by bustamove View Post
    Sure seems to me the whole Paleo movement is nothing more than Atkins Diet reborn again...?? Unless I'm missing something?? Atkins preached high protien with hefty healthy fats and low to no carbs. So why is Paleo better or more advanced than Atkins?? Just wondering - thanks
    No. It isn't.

    Get a copy of the Paleo Diet and have a look. Cordain is actually preaching something more like moderate carb. He characterizes the "paleo" diet as "high protein, low glycemic index".

    Current Atkins is moderate (not high) protein and low carb. Cordain is saying high (not moderate) protein and moderate (not low) carb. Cordain actually gives a figure of 22% to 40% carbs. Not low. He wants the carbs to be low glycemic index, so he appreciates they hold dangers for stable blood-sugar levels, but he's prepared to countenance up to 40% of calories as carbs, so he's not really low-carb.

    I'm not at all sure he's right in this. But that is what he's saying.

    There's a lot more to it than this, but even at this level -- simple discussion of macronutrients, the (current) Atkins and the paleo strategies are different.

  7. #37
    Owly's Avatar
    Owly is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    3,823
    Quote Originally Posted by BennettC View Post
    agreed. sorry for getting so defensive, in fact I had a beer yesterday lol
    No worries. I have celiac disease, and your beer would make me very, very ill. We all have different reactions to things.
    “If I didn't define myself for myself, I would be crunched into other people's fantasies for me and eaten alive.” --Audre Lorde

    Owly's Journal

  8. #38
    BennettC's Avatar
    BennettC is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2012
    Location
    Beaufot, SC
    Posts
    528
    I started on his version, its rough. no dairy, no bacon, low fat. he tells you to eat all you want and that's where he screws up
    Paleo since November 2011 - Carnivore since June 2012
    Before and after pics
    http://www.marksdailyapple.com/forum/thread65846.html
    Primal Sucess Story
    http://www.marksdailyapple.com/forum/thread65400.html
    Primal Journal
    http://www.marksdailyapple.com/forum...tml#post955444

  9. #39
    Scott F's Avatar
    Scott F is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Location
    Texas
    Posts
    930
    According to Dr Johnson's book, The Fat Switch, the Inuit's macro diet was 50% fat, 35% protein, and 15% glycogen from the animals they ate. Average intake was 3000 calories.

    Here's the problem with a vlc diet. It can increase your uric acid production through the breakdown of proteins (muscle or diet). Exercising excessively will also raise uric acid levels through the breakdown of muscle. Too low a body fat % will also up uric acid production. Hibernating animals that didn't put on enough fat for winter will come out of hibernation in a last ditch effort to find food once their fat supplies have exhausted. The trigger that wakes them up is high uric acid.
    Would I be putting a grain-feed cow on a fad diet if I took it out of the feedlot and put it on pasture eating the grass nature intended?

  10. #40
    Lewis's Avatar
    Lewis is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Posts
    2,344
    Quote Originally Posted by Scott F View Post
    According to Dr Johnson's book, The Fat Switch, the Inuit's macro diet was 50% fat, 35% protein, and 15% glycogen from the animals they ate. Average intake was 3000 calories.

    Here's the problem with a vlc diet. It can increase your uric acid production through the breakdown of proteins (muscle or diet). Exercising excessively will also raise uric acid levels through the breakdown of muscle. Too low a body fat % will also up uric acid production. Hibernating animals that didn't put on enough fat for winter will come out of hibernation in a last ditch effort to find food once their fat supplies have exhausted. The trigger that wakes them up is high uric acid.
    That's certainly not what the OP was asking.

    However, if this needs any comment ... I don't know who Dr. Johnson is, or why he thinks he knows, but reliable sources seem to indicate that the traditional Inuit diet was something like 80% fat and 20% protein with a pretty negligible carbohydrate content. That certainly seems to be what Stefansson says -- and how he was eating during the Bellevue Hospital experiment. The notion that one could get 15% of one's calories from muscle glycogen is preposterous.

    And no, that's a perfectly silly piece of mythologization of what would happen on a VLC diet. You know, it comes down to this: the sources are out there: read them:

    The Art and Science of Low Carbohydrate Living: An Expert Guide to Making the Life-Saving Benefits of Carbohydrate Restriction Sustainable and Enjoyable: Stephen D. Phinney,Jeff S. Volek: 9780983490708: Amazon.com: Books

    Or don't. But don't comment on the basis of not having done so.

Page 4 of 8 FirstFirst ... 23456 ... LastLast

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •