Good luck! You may be very muscular, but I'm 6', 33 waist, and 180 or so, and the pinch test at the gym said I'm 19% bodyfat. Could be the extra height, could be my gym did it wrong, and could be you've got way more in the way of muscle weight than I do, though. Or maybe my fat is lower than they said!
Either way, I agree with you...paleo is just too much. After just one week of Primal, though, I'm already feeling better overall, so hopefully the same will work for you.