futuretrpr, all your numbers are completely normal. LDL is optimal between 100 and 160, so your non-Lipitor LDL of 140 is normal and healthy but your Lipitor LDL is too low. Optimal HDL is 60+, so you're a bit below the ideal, but certainly at a normal level. Total cholesterol optimal is 200 to 240.
That you feel bad on Lipitor is a warning sign. It is damaging your health.
See wildwabbit's link to my blog for more info. Re HDL, see HDL and Immunity | Perfect Health Diet for a start.