
Originally Posted by
spuggygirl
Aargghhh. Shame is that people believe this guff!
My mother has always been one of them - fat-phobic and believing everything she reads in the daily mail. She's just been diagnosed with high cholesterol (strange, if you believe CW, since she has cut every visible shred of fat off everything and cooked with as little fat as possible for years!). I had another conversation with her this weekend about eating more healthy fats and, after questioning coconut oil for being a saturated fat, I actually think I got through to her. I don't think she'll be going primal anytime soon, but if I can get her to eat avocados, butter and cook with coconut oil without fearing for her life, get her to eat less bread and stop buying that kind of plastic margarine nonsense, I'll feel much better.
There are laws against false advertising in the UK, but it's tricky when the government are spouting the same lies.
Question for the board: if you could convince a SAD friend to do only one thing, is it better to cut down on bread/wheat, or start eating better fats? I believe that Mark wrote that just switching to coconut oil is the single best thing to do, healthwise. But as we know, if you don't know what to look for, those health effects are largely invisible. I'm afraid that the combination of butter/CO/oil without reducing carbs is likely to make a SAD gain weight, which is VERY visible. And they would be more likely to blame the coconut oil, not the bread, swear off Primal, and go back to margerine.
It's hard to call something false advertising when there aren't solid standards to compare against. In the US there are good definitions for "artificial" or "imitation," so companies can't make false claims. But we have no standards as to what will lower cholesterol (assuming we even want to lower cholesterol) or what is heart-healthy. So SAD food companies are free to manipulate the language however they want.
The American Heart Association even has a "heart healthy" label which a company can pay the AHA to plaster on the product box. They talk about this in Fathead.
5'0" female, 42 years old.
Started Primal October 31, 2011, at a skinny fat 111.5 lbs.
Current weight: 101.5. lbs and holding steady. Spring yardwork here we come!
Co-worker 1: Needs to lose ~50. Now he wants to start Mayo Clinic Diet. Yeesh. Give it up, man.
Co-worker 2: Needed to lose ~55. Lost 20 from stress. Started Primal in Sept, lost 20 more, but gained 10 back on a carb spree. We're working on it.