My feeling is that the more we strengthen our feet by being unsupported/barefoot, the less we need any arch support. The more we use arch supports, the more we need them. Should just make that transition back to strong feet slowly and carefully to avoid injuring your feet that have not had to hold themselves up for a long time. If you are transitioning to barefoot running for example, the guidance is that your soles will toughen more quickly than your feet will strengthen. Take your time.