Did a little delving into some of the products we sell here at the Co-Op, and was very pleased with the Pasture Maid Creamery. They're based out of New Castle, not too far from the city.
Even has a link to the WAPF on the main site!
Their milk is delicious - I drink a lot of it. Recently inquired as to whether he has any cream available. (Fingers crossed!)
Will let y'all know how that pans out.