Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Looking for lite version of Crossfit

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Looking for lite version of Crossfit

    Hi everyone,

    I need some suggestions/direction on what kind of fitness class to participate in that is like Crossfit but not as intense. I tried it for a week and learned that I am definitely not interested in that level of exercise. However, I do want to reap the benefit of strength training but in a group exercise setting. I love the group dynamic that Crossfit inspires but I abhor the militaristic rigor of it. Does a program exist that could be described as Crossfit lite?

    Any and all feedback is appreciated, thanks!!

  • #2
    You might want to check out different CrossFit boxes for a different vibe. All of them are different...some more laid back without that militaristic style of instruction.

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by nikatoah View Post
      ...I do want to reap the benefit of strength training but in a group exercise setting.
      Just to clarify: CrossFit is not strength training. CrossFit entails some strength training, and as a novice you will initially get stronger by doing CrossFit, but long-term CrossFit will not provide your body with the proper stimulus to drive strength gains.

      Do you want to do CrossFit, or do you want to strength train? I would answer that question first.

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by quikky View Post
        Just to clarify: CrossFit is not strength training. CrossFit entails some strength training, and as a novice you will initially get stronger by doing CrossFit, but long-term CrossFit will not provide your body with the proper stimulus to drive strength gains.

        Do you want to do CrossFit, or do you want to strength train? I would answer that question first.
        I've been doing CrossFit for almost three years. I'm still improving in every single lift at age 51. My dead has gone from 365 to 435 doing only CrossFit. My back squat has gone from 265 to 375. I think your statement about CrossFit is too general. It's true of some boxes, I'm sure.

        But more and more boxes are using an approach more like the CrossFit football approach, and that includes heavy periodized power lifts and Oly lifts.

        It's possible that I would have gotten stronger training on my own. But, CrossFit is absolutely providing the stimulus to drive strength gains for me.

        Comment


        • #5
          My Crossfit place has 2 days of strength only, one day of strength and a short metcon and two days of metcons. It's a lot of lifting. We squat and deadlift a ton. I think they care MORE about how you squat, deadlift and bench press than how you do on some met con. I'd actually say the met cons seem like an after thought sometimes. You'd probably like where I work out- we get our strength workout and break out into groups and do that with some trainer oversight. Then if we have a met con we do that all together, but no one is really yelling at you or being a drill sargeant.

          Probably the problem with CrossFit is that it is not uniform, so who knows what you experienced. It's not like say, a Curves franchise where you do the same thing in every location.

          http://maggiesfeast.wordpress.com/
          Check out my blog. Hope to share lots of great recipes and ideas!

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by dml View Post
            I've been doing CrossFit for almost three years. I'm still improving in every single lift at age 51. My dead has gone from 365 to 435 doing only CrossFit. My back squat has gone from 265 to 375. I think your statement about CrossFit is too general. It's true of some boxes, I'm sure.
            Imagine the gains you could have had doing dedicated strength training.

            Originally posted by dml View Post
            But more and more boxes are using an approach more like the CrossFit football approach, and that includes heavy periodized power lifts and Oly lifts.
            If I open a gym, spend a couple hours with a PVC pipe earning my level 1, pay my affiliation fee, and tell everybody to squat, deadlift, bench, press, and power clean (but I call it a "WOD"), is it CrossFit?

            Originally posted by dml View Post
            It's possible that I would have gotten stronger training on my own. But, CrossFit is absolutely providing the stimulus to drive strength gains for me.
            Great. What would have happened if you had instead signed up for a powerlifting meet and joined a gym where other people compete in such things? Do you think that stimulus would have driven more strength gains for you? I'll bet it would have.
            The Champagne of Beards

            Comment


            • #7
              People are starting to call anything CrossFit these days. Oh, yeah, if your gym has kettlebells, does clean and jerks, and "WODs", it must be CrossFit.

              CrossFit is a brand of circuit training. If you are not following the methods of Glassman & Co. you are not doing CrossFit.

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by magnolia1973 View Post
                My Crossfit place has 2 days of strength only, one day of strength and a short metcon and two days of metcons. It's a lot of lifting. We squat and deadlift a ton. I think they care MORE about how you squat, deadlift and bench press than how you do on some met con. I'd actually say the met cons seem like an after thought sometimes. You'd probably like where I work out- we get our strength workout and break out into groups and do that with some trainer oversight. Then if we have a met con we do that all together, but no one is really yelling at you or being a drill sargeant.

                Probably the problem with CrossFit is that it is not uniform, so who knows what you experienced. It's not like say, a Curves franchise where you do the same thing in every location.
                Sounds like you're basically doing strength training with CrossFit-style conditioning thrown in. That's not CrossFit.

                Comment


                • #9
                  By Cross-fit I take it you mean the over hyped gym classes that encourage poor form, over training and crazy joining costs !

                  I'd just join a good gym and read some articles by Drew Baye etc. Train hard and brief using strict slow form to failure.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Wow, I've read very little constructive feedback here. Mostly a bunch of sour retorts. Kind of discourages me from participating in these forums.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by geoffspakes View Post
                      Wow, I've read very little constructive feedback here. Mostly a bunch of sour retorts. Kind of discourages me from participating in these forums.
                      So sorry we disappointed you. We'll certainly miss you. Thanks for the constructive feedback!
                      The Champagne of Beards

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by geoffspakes View Post
                        Wow, I've read very little constructive feedback here. Mostly a bunch of sour retorts. Kind of discourages me from participating in these forums.
                        I think the overwhelming promotion of Crossfit leaves a bad taste with some. It's a business, not a workout.

                        What did people do before Crossfit? Nothing?

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by RichMahogany View Post
                          So sorry we disappointed you. We'll certainly miss you. Thanks for the constructive feedback!
                          Just what I'm talking about. If you look at my initial response you'll see that it was actually constructive and tried to provide help. It didn't make smarmy remarks like some others.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Y'all need to re-read the original post. It didn't ask for opinions, positive or negative, on CrossFit yet they all came flying out the window.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by RichMahogany View Post
                              So sorry we disappointed you. We'll certainly miss you. Thanks for the constructive feedback!
                              What a warm and friendly response. I feel so welcome.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X