If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
No announcement yet.
sporadic fitness all day long (grazing) VS. daily "all-at-once" workout
To simplify this idea further- isn't this he way most people lived up until very recently, probably post war. It is only in the last 50 years or so that he majority of the population have been desk bound. Before that they worked manual jobs for 8-10 hours per day which is after all a form of exercise which runs continuously throughout the day.
You can talk about doing specific exercises for set & reps or until failure but is that more effective than doing construction work every day. I've recently bought a small farm which keeps me very busy walking, carrying, digging the majority of time and I've seriously never been in better shape. Even with very little formal exercise I'm leaner and stronger than before when I followed a conventional program. Certainly an improved Primal diet has helped as well.
When thing are hectic I get through the day, if things are quieter I may add in some Movnat style movements.
The two things I do concentrat on are mobility & stretching (most days) and some kind of intuitive control I.e. if I'm feeling tired I do try to back off a bit- I'm never constrained by the idea of having to do X amount of work in a day.
It's a great subject. Personally I put on over 30lbs in 14months once by eating LOADS and following DC training (high intensity, rest pause. I got really strong and big (about 210 and 10% bf). It stopped being fun having to eat so much and my joints were taking a pounding.
Now, the debate is on. From a bodyweight movement standpoint, do u go with marks LHT program which has you hitting failure, or follow JP from the site strength villain who has his guys do 'frequency method' pushups/chins etc fringe the day and is seeing great carry over into strenth.
I like pushing to failure and am on the advanced movements in marks LHT program, but I also like doing something everday and would happily do more pushups, chins etc at the moment but havnt as I know I will be over training if I try and do them alongside the LHT failure workouts.
I just have to decide which I have a stronger desire to do b/c both will bring results (one probably quicker than the other but that depends on the individual and how they approach training and also how they react to it).
As an aside. If you are looking for daily exercises, or what may be classed as a monthly challenge (or just to have a look), I strongly, strongly recommend you google 'villanous challenge 1' .... then look up ' villanous challenge 2' etc etc (there are 5). This will give you some great goals to work towards, some that require daily work (sometimes multiple times a day if u want to), others that require a session or two a week (potentially something for everyone no matter where you stand on this debate). You can all thank me later haha.
I think like the CICO debate this is one of those 'horses for courses' things. What works is what you can stick to and don't hate and can see/feel working. Anything is better than nowt.
Personally this is what I'm doing and it's working for me. Move Slowly - walking often, normally to get baby to sleep, prob at least 3 hrs per week, often more. LHT - Mark's PBF every Saturday - to failure on most things, I've just done a set of 50 push ups, up from 45 max last week, squats I'm doing full body weight x 50 going deep, pull ups are weak, about 5 neutral grip, just done a set of 8 negatives to failure this week. Overhead press - feet on window sill, which is about mid thigh height for me. Progress is decent IMO and I get plenty of rest. I sprint on tuesdays - don't time, just run like satan is chasing me 8 times. I go for a long run on Thursdays - adding a mile a week as I'm wanting to do a 10 mile run at the end of October, and want to do a marathon next year just to tick it off
I like pushing myself, getting sweaty and feeling the effort. My other half finds that weird and would much rather do stuff like sandstone - farm work, all day, as she says there is always something she would be rarther doing than working out and dosn't want it to be something separate she has to decide to do, but something that just happens.
You know all those pictures of Adam and Eve where they have belly button? Think about it..................... take as long as you need........................