Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

CrossFit on a Low-Carb Primal or Paleo Diet

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • CrossFit on a Low-Carb Primal or Paleo Diet

    In a prior thread I asked about frequency of CrossFitting for a relatively out of shape 40-something year old. This past week I started CrossFitting and so far so good, but after the intro/"Baseline" workout I was really dizzy and felt a bit 'out of it' the next day. So I ate a lot more carbs than I usually do, mostly in the form of bananas and coconut milk, and some yogurt.

    But I'm concerned that adding in these carbs will cause me to either bulk up or gain weight, which I don't want to do. I don't care about the scale number, but after successfully dropping 65 pounds and maintaining it for 6 months pretty effortlessly, the last thing I want to do is see it come back.

    After only two CrossFit sessions (the baseline and a single one-on-one 'Fundamentals' class), I already see and feel noticeable physical changes, which is astonishing to me - I see the "V" shape more clearly from my chest to gut, though my gut still is flabby. And I definitely notice more muscular definition. So I'm STOKED about the possibilities of CrossFit. BUT....I don't *feel* as good. I feel a bit sluggish still. And I'm eating a lot more, thinking I need to to compensate for the increase in physical activity. This has concerned me as I have a fear of getting fat again, and I don't want to do that just to crossfit : )

    Then, this morning I saw this:

    CrossFit On a Low Carb Paleo Diet: Mat Lalonde Reporting

    Mat Lalonde states it took him a couple of weeks to get acclimated to a low-carb paleo diet while crossfitting, but once he did, he excelled. Something tells me that a super-fit guy like him is someone I probably shouldn't be comparing my flabby-gut 40-something self to, but it's the best I've come up with in terms of my simple question:

    Aside from the carbs I get from non-starchy vegetables, do I need to add more carbs? Or should I just focus on adding more fat and protein?

    This past week I was thinking I need to carb-load/refeed/delve into gluttony : ) But after reading Mat's article, I'm thinking I'm going to try sticking out a couple of weeks of CrossFit (and later this coming week it will be real WODs, as I am set to finish Fundamentals on Tuesday with a monster 1.5 hour personal training session).

    Has anyone here been through this? I'm really hoping someone has had this same concern, experienced the sluggishness/lethargy when starting CrossFit (or a similar high-intensity program) and 'stuck it out' for a couple of weeks and can state their results?

    mark
    Low Carb Learning

  • #2
    How low-carb are you going?

    I ate a ton of carbs when I first started Crossfit and still felt like crap for weeks - it's not an easy workout program!

    Comment


    • #3
      I tried low carb and Crossfit together for a while, but I've found I do better with more carbs (100-150g range generally) and have still been successfully leaning out at the same time.
      “If I didn't define myself for myself, I would be crunched into other people's fantasies for me and eaten alive.” --Audre Lorde

      Owly's Journal

      Comment


      • #4
        I didn't do well with low Carb either. I upped my carbs to 125g and feel amazing now and I'm still dropping weight every single week. I started with needing to drop 35lbs.

        Comment


        • #5
          Don't trust that article, it irks me that it was never updated by Lalonde himself said on a podcast that going low-carb and keeping up crossfit eventually caught up with him and he bottomed out hard. According to the podcast he had to eat two pints of ice cream after a workout once because he needed to get his sugar up quick. I can't remember what podcast it was, but if you do a search for one with lalonde on it, a few months after this article it was one of the topics. They really should make a note on it, it's very misleading as is.

          If you ENJOY eating low-carb (don't care not to eat much fruit, don't care for rice, etc), then make sure to carb refeed every now and then. If you're somebody that LIKES to eat starches daily (or you don't want to cut down on fruits, etc) then just eat conscious carbs everyday to fuel your performance.
          I used to seriously post here, now I prefer to troll.

          Comment


          • #6
            Thanks iniquity. I will look for that podcast.

            In the meantime - I'd better start adding more carbs to my diet just in case. I'd rather put on a few extra pounds that walk around in a haze and not be able to put 100% effort into my CrossFit sessions. Thinking about this topic more...it makes sense that carbs would be necessary. My limited (mainly due to lack of interest) understanding in the science is that the body uses carbs for intense movement, particulary for short 'fight or flight' periods, but fat is utilized best when doing low-intensity movement. If this is in fact the case, then to be on the safe side I'm going to add more carbs into my day to day, particular the day before/of CrossFit sessions, and see how it goes.

            Comment


            • #7
              This fella does as much if not more intense stuff Keto Peter Attia | The War on Insulin | Peter Attia, M.D., explains why everything you think you know about nutrition is wrong. Eating fat does not make you fat.

              Oh, for the record I do eat low carb, but I don't do crossfit. I also go to a sushi buffet once a week. Not for a carb refeed or anythin, I just love sushi and they also have seaweed salad and some good bivalves and stuff. I recognize that although not a conscious effort this may be working as a refeed for me. Either way have at it!
              Last edited by Neckhammer; 05-28-2012, 07:01 PM.

              Comment


              • #8
                iniQuity,

                THANK YOU for taking the time to respond letting me know about Matt's retraction to his article. I found the podcast where he discussed his experience. In a nutshell, he finished with:

                “Don’t do that.” “If you are going to burn carbohydrate, eat carbohydrate.” He recommends starchy stuff like yucca root, peeled potatoes for this. “If you are going to do high-intensity exercise, you should eat the carbohydrate that goes along with it.”

                I updated my blog on this topic if anyone is interested:
                CrossFit on a Low Carb Paleo or Primal Diet | Low Carb Learning

                Direct link to the source podcast where Matt discusses his experience is here: The Paleo Solution | Paleolithic nutrition, intermittent fasting, and fitness (starts at 44:07)

                Of course, this doesn't truly ANSWER anything. Matt says that you need carbs to do CrossFit. Okay...how much? That still remains a mystery to me. In the meantime, I indulged in a serious treat tonight (ice cream) in anticipation of a 1.5 hour condensed personal training session tomorrow morning, and will make sure to eat a large sweet potato either before or after each WOD this week that I do. I plan on doing 3x per week. Wish me luck! : )

                Again - iniQuity - thank you for letting me know of this. You may have saved me some serious side effects.

                mark
                Low Carb Learning

                Comment


                • #9
                  Neckhammer,

                  I actually asked Dr. Attia via the comments on his blog about this (though this was long before I started CrossFit). He said that it took him quite a while to adapt to being able to exercise hard on low carb. IIRC, a year and a half or so.

                  From my standpoint - I don't understand why one would have to condition themselves to exercise hard while eating low carb. I can see a week or two, but months? Years? Doesn't seem right to me. I defer to Dr. Attia of course but for me, I'm going to try 'carbing up' to avoid hitting the wall like I've been doing repeatedly when exercising at high-intensity. This is a problem that's been holding me back for almost a year now - last Summer it was typical weightlifting (with rest between sets). So I was/am very concerned about being able to sustain a CrossFit routine. Based on Matt's experience, my concerns were warranted.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Months and years make sense in the context of physiological adaptation, but I'm not for or against either method (carbing). Read my edited version .

                    Hey if you are a cross fit athlete, and thats what your in it for I would think some well timed carb ups would be beneficial. I'm actually quite skeptical of crossfit as a method of obtaining and/or maintaining health though. Just saying, thats why I don't do it and keep my HIT sessions to one or two a week with plenty of low and slow in between. That is quite off topic though.

                    With High Intensity Training 1-2x a week I have seen consistent gains for over 6 months (either reps or weight increasing on a weekly basis). Could be the low carbing for you, or it could be that its just not good for a forty something to be hitting it that hard THAT FREQUENTLY. We take a bit more recovery time with age.
                    Last edited by Neckhammer; 05-28-2012, 07:12 PM.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by mark2741 View Post
                      iniQuity,

                      THANK YOU for taking the time to respond letting me know about Matt's retraction to his article. I found the podcast where he discussed his experience. In a nutshell, he finished with:

                      “Don’t do that.” “If you are going to burn carbohydrate, eat carbohydrate.” He recommends starchy stuff like yucca root, peeled potatoes for this. “If you are going to do high-intensity exercise, you should eat the carbohydrate that goes along with it.”

                      I updated my blog on this topic if anyone is interested:
                      CrossFit on a Low Carb Paleo or Primal Diet | Low Carb Learning

                      Direct link to the source podcast where Matt discusses his experience is here: The Paleo Solution | Paleolithic nutrition, intermittent fasting, and fitness (starts at 44:07)

                      Of course, this doesn't truly ANSWER anything. Matt says that you need carbs to do CrossFit. Okay...how much? That still remains a mystery to me. In the meantime, I indulged in a serious treat tonight (ice cream) in anticipation of a 1.5 hour condensed personal training session tomorrow morning, and will make sure to eat a large sweet potato either before or after each WOD this week that I do. I plan on doing 3x per week. Wish me luck! : )

                      Again - iniQuity - thank you for letting me know of this. You may have saved me some serious side effects.

                      mark
                      Low Carb Learning
                      No problem, I'm glad I was able to. I attempted going pretty low carb and upping exercise myself with bad effects, as a result of reading that article but before hearing the podcast. You should write to Rob or someone on his team to update that article.

                      With regards to how much carb to eat, you should just experiment, because the number depends on many things including your activity level, age, physiology, etc, no two people will be the same here. Also depends on your goals, of course. As far as when to eat the carbs, also don't think it's a huge deal, just make sure your body is well fed and nourished and it will respond to exercise.
                      I used to seriously post here, now I prefer to troll.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Thanks again. About once every 2 months, I get an itch to grab a pint of Ben & Jerry's "Everything But The..." ice cream and treat myself. Last night I figured would be a good time to satisfy it : )

                        I had a combined Fundamentals session this morning from 8:30 to 10. I felt pretty good and although I was sweating like crazy and at the end was pretty winded, I feel *right* now - a little sore (good sore), but energized.

                        I won't be eating Ben & Jerry's again anytime soon but I will start making a point to add a sweet potato/bananas more and go from there.

                        Thanks again!

                        mark
                        Low Carb Learning

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by iniQuity View Post
                          Don't trust that article, it irks me that it was never updated by Lalonde himself said on a podcast that going low-carb and keeping up crossfit eventually caught up with him and he bottomed out hard. According to the podcast he had to eat two pints of ice cream after a workout once because he needed to get his sugar up quick. I can't remember what podcast it was, but if you do a search for one with lalonde on it, a few months after this article it was one of the topics. They really should make a note on it, it's very misleading as is.

                          If you ENJOY eating low-carb (don't care not to eat much fruit, don't care for rice, etc), then make sure to carb refeed every now and then. If you're somebody that LIKES to eat starches daily (or you don't want to cut down on fruits, etc) then just eat conscious carbs everyday to fuel your performance.
                          i think it was an old robb wolf podcast from a while ago. if i remember correctly, matt had to run in tothe ben and jerry's in harvard square and gobble down all that ice cream to basically keep from croaking.

                          on a side note, i've been having success in cycling my carb intake to one day of high carb and then one day of low carb. high usually is about 150-200 grams and low is about 50 grams. i don't do crossfit, but my training tends to be just as intense/if not more intense and of all the carb methods, this one has worked out the best for me in terms of muscle growth/fat loss, and not having a negative impact on my performance

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            If anyone is still around I do Crossfit and eat about 30 to 80 carbs a day. I have not figured out how and when to eat more carbs on workout days or if I need too. I am a naturally big guy and do very well on protien only. I dont miss carbs but Im not sure if it effecting my workouts. I love white rice and sweet potatoe. Should I have a nice portion by them selfs after a work out.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by stevejill91 View Post
                              If anyone is still around I do Crossfit and eat about 30 to 80 carbs a day. I have not figured out how and when to eat more carbs on workout days or if I need too. I am a naturally big guy and do very well on protien only. I dont miss carbs but Im not sure if it effecting my workouts. I love white rice and sweet potatoe. Should I have a nice portion by them selfs after a work out.
                              Eating high glycemic carbs after a workout is the optimum time to have them.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X