Marks Daily Apple
Serving up health and fitness insights (daily, of course) with a side of irreverence.
18 Sep

Egg Purchasing Guide

Ah, eggs. We Primals appreciate your delicious creamy yolky goodness and fluffy decadent ivory insides, like so many edible clouds upon whose buoyancy our breakfast relies. You’re good for us and come naturally pre-packaged. What’s not to love?

The myriad terms used to describe them, for one.

Cage free. Organic. All natural. Free range. You see these terms on egg cartons all the time, some even using all four at once! But what do they mean? Does “free range” mean access to a chicken’s natural, Primal diet? Let’s examine each nebulous term for what it’s worth.

Free Range

As applied to chicken eggs, this term is essentially meaningless. Government only loosely regulates the definition of “free range,” and egg producers have jumped at the opportunity to print some new labels and charge a couple extra bucks in return for giving their hens occasional access to a tiny patch of dirt. According to the Department of Agriculture (PDF), egg “producers must demonstrate to the Agency that the poultry has been allowed access to the Outside” In other words, there needs to be a door to the chicken cage, and it needs to be open part of the time, but the chickens can still eat substandard food and live in cramped conditions. A “range” can range from being a full-fledged pasture (not likely) to a 10 x 10 patch of manure and dirt (more likely). Chances are, most free range chickens rarely even venture outside. Why would they? Their food is usually inside.

Cage Free

Even more meaningless than “free range,” this term has no legal definition. Technically, cage free hens don’t live in stifling metal cages; instead, they might still live in stifling, overcrowded henhouses! Some cage free hens’ lives aren’t much qualitatively better than those who live in cages and most still aren’t getting any access to the outdoors, but they’re generally raised with better food and better treatment.

Organic

Organic is more useful and easy to pin down. Organic egg producing hens are given organic feed, no antibiotics (unless in the case of an outbreak), and limited access to the outdoors (just a door to their cage or barn, really). These are better than your average mass-produced egg, but your best bet is still to find a truly pasture-raised egg.

All Natural

Um, “all natural”? As opposed to artificial? This is the most useless, all-encompassing term for anything. All produce is natural. These eggs weren’t created in a lab by a team of white coats. Even the most steroid-pumped, antibiotic-immersed hens produce “natural” eggs the way nature intended: by laying them. “All natural” is just a subtly disingenuous term used to conjure up images of hens happily pecking away at seeds and bounding through pastures, only to return home for the nightly egg-laying. It’s a feel-good phrase that distracts consumers from the fact that most eggs are produced in appalling, wholly unnatural conditions. Feel free to eat all natural eggs, but don’t be fooled into thinking they’re of any particular improvement in quality.

Omega-3 Fortified

Omega-3 fortified eggs come from hens fed flax, linseed, or a direct supplement. The healthy fats do trickle down to the consumer, but in varying degrees. Seeds (especially flax) aren’t the greatest source of omega-3 fats anyway, so we would advise you not to rely on the fortified eggs for your healthy fat source. Buy these if you like – omega-3 fortified eggs also tend to come from organic, cage-free birds, so they’re generally better – but stick with the fish oil, too.

The Bottom Line

As Primal Blueprinters are fastidious about what we eat, we should also pay attention to what our food eats. Chickens raised in stressful environments – eating corn, soy, and antibiotics (a decidedly unPrimal diet for a chicken), and relegated to a tiny cage that would result in atrophy were it not for the steroids – do not produce high quality eggs. Your best bet is to research the egg producers. Free range and cage free are good starts, but it’s not the end of it. Find out if their birds are actually free range, and not just given access to a patch of dirt. If the hens are out their pecking away in a pasture, digging for grubs and worms and eating wild grasses, they’re going to produce eggs that are much more inline with how nature intends it.

A study (PDF) of fourteen free range chicken farms conducted by Mother Earth News (I know, I know, how hippy-dippy can you get?) confirms that true pasture/range free chickens, given a natural diet of grains, insects, grasses, and seeds, produce eggs loaded with nutrients. Pasture raised eggs have more beta-carotene, vitamins E and A, and omega-3 levels, with less cholesterol and saturated fat than mass-market eggs.

The choice is pretty clear. If you can afford it, look for local varieties of pasture raised eggs. Try the farmer’s market or gourmet grocery stores. If not, at least stick with organic, cage free, free range eggs. Their chickens may not have been out frolicking, but at least they weren’t stuffed into cages and force-fed drugs. Your wallet may hurt in the short term, but – as we Primal Blueprinters know better than anyone else – your long-term health is worth the extra expense.

ANDI2.. Flickr Photo (CC)

Further Reading:

Primal Breakfast Suggestions for People on the Go

Eggs, Breakfast and Weight Loss

How to Make a Delicious Spanish Omelet

Mother Earth News: Meet Real Free Range Eggs

EatWild.com

You want comments? We got comments:

Imagine you’re George Clooney. Take a moment to admire your grooming and wit. Okay, now imagine someone walks up to you and asks, “What’s your name?” You say, “I’m George Clooney.” Or maybe you say, “I’m the Clooninator!” You don’t say “I’m George of George Clooney Sells Movies Blog” and you certainly don’t say, “I’m Clooney Weight Loss Plan”. So while spam is technically meat, it ain’t anywhere near Primal. Please nickname yourself something your friends would call you.

  1. We never knew how enjoyable having chickens could be until we bit the bullet and got some. Each passing year we learn more about our delightful chickens. They roam freely, and are fed organic feed. The summer yolks are actually orange! We have yet to buy eggs that are better – even from farmers’ markets.

    Lynnette wrote on September 28th, 2011
  2. Europe has a great solution to this egg issue, its the exploding market called BIO or biological according to the best life (possible) for the animal and its organic, non-genetic altering for produce, milk, cheese, etc, as well.
    If a food has the special bio marking, like a chicken egg, it means not only was the bird raised according to ITS needs it was fed also according to the bio criteria. In Germany for example you can buy eggs caged (Kaefighaltung), barn/ground (Bodenhaltung), Outdoor (Freilandhaltung) and Bio. Each step of the way the bird and egg gets a bit better, but only with bio can you be sure that the chicken had a decent life. It’s very hard for a farmer to maintain the bio rating because his whole operation must be bio,, but the advantage for the farmer is a slightly higher price for the egg and I guess the knowledge that he is making real food. The good news of this system is you don’t have to wonder around half the world looking for barefoot hippies selling organic out of VW buses to get your quality food, you just go to any store and look for the bio marked foods. Buy the way, you can also get omega-3 eggs, but they are no longer classified as bio (at least the ones I saw so far, not sure about the food regulation on that) so what chicken was it? The one on the cage? Probably.

    William wrote on October 14th, 2011
  3. i like eggs

    Tyler `15 wrote on October 18th, 2011
    • I like turtles

      Joe wrote on October 24th, 2011
      • I like trains

        Harriet wrote on November 14th, 2013
  4. One of the few reasons worth living in kansas.. access to cheap, farm fresh, food :D. I can get a dozen of pastured chicken eggs for $3.50 from my preferred farmer. They taste soooo much better than the store bought stuff. Thanks for the article, passing this one onto my family members who struggle to figure out the deceptive carton labels.

    Greg wrote on February 6th, 2012
  5. Interesting post! I don’t think anyone has commented on this yet, apologies if this came up already. But from what I’ve read, many of the non-pastured hens might actually be eating diets that have the macronutrients most resembling their natural diets (albeit, animal parts vs. worms). So, if you can’t find/afford pastured, given the choice between “cage free, all vegetarian” and simply “cage free”, I’d go cage free. Does that sound right to folks? See here: http://www.examiner.com/wellness-in-new-york/eggs-101-the-difference-between-free-range-cage-free-pasture-raised-organic-natural-omega-3

    PaleoVenus wrote on March 3rd, 2012
  6. P.S. the author of the post i linked to above has a bias toward all-vegetarian fed chickens and has an “ick” factor for animal parts being fed to chickens. i guess that’s what I’m questioning.

    PaleoVenus wrote on March 3rd, 2012
  7. mother earth new’s isn’t just for hippies, its for people who want to be self sufficient and prefer to live with their heads in the air as opposed to firmly planted in the sand. Just my 2 cents

    nick wrote on June 26th, 2012
  8. For people in the UK, the best supermarket eggs I’m aware of are Sainsbury’s Free Range Woodland eggs – at least 20% of the birds’ range area planted with a mix of native tree cover to encourage the birds out to forage in the first place.

    http://www.j-sainsbury.co.uk/suppliers/working-with-the-woodland-trust/

    I’d be interested to hear about any other UK supermarket options that may be as good/better. Thanks!

    Kirsten wrote on November 30th, 2012
  9. If you can only get normal, mass produced eggs, is it still better to eat them than to not eat eggs at all? In India it is not possible (or at least not possible in normal cities) to find fancy organic, free range, etc. eggs. Eggs are widely available and cheap, but the way they have been produced is suspect. I sometimes worry that this makes the eggs not only lower in quality, but in fact potentially unhealthy? Is this true? I am a vegetarian (yes to dairy, no to eggs) trying to transition to eating eggs and then on to meat. I want to go for a month with an egg rich diet before adding meat, as I feel even eggs themselves will be a big step. Is it ok to go with mass produced eggs?

    Jaya wrote on August 12th, 2013
  10. great post, very informative. I live in a rural area and have a local farm i get eggs from. THey are a staple in my diet so i am very picky, and wondering if i could get some thoughts on the quality of their diet/health?

    There are 99 hens (100 is the limit here) and they have access to a decent size of pasture anytime the sun is up. (decent size meaning 70 feet by 70 feet or so)
    At night they are locked up for safety.
    THey are fed ground oyster shells, organic feed (contains corn and other grains) as well as some flaxseed.

    Ive personally seen the hens running around and i know the feed brand name so i know he is 100% telling the truth. At $3.50/dozen im hoping that the feeding them corn isnt ruining all the other great aspects of it.

    Thanks for any thought.
    -Ron

    Ron wrote on February 16th, 2014
  11. hi,

    i love your blog and all it’s wisdom. i’m upset by your brushing off free range and cage free eggs. in an ideal world, we’d all have our own chickens, or know farmers to get eggs from. considering that the average urban dweller doesn’t, isn’t “free range” or “cage free” the next best thing for someone shopping at Ralphs?
    completely agree that the industry takes advantage of these labels. they also do with the label “organic.” what matters is that the hens in the free range/cage free farms get better treatment. they’re still a much better alternative to the average farm.

    libby wrote on February 25th, 2014
  12. Hi I’m in south africa, our eggs are okay haven’t seen a dark orange I didn’t really take notice of wat eggs my parents buy, thanks for the info, I have one question, I love to crack two raw eggs into a glass cup adding a teaspoon of sugar and mixing it up with a little milk .. Is this healthy? I usually have 3 cups a day of this stuff

    radlan wrote on May 15th, 2014

Leave a Reply

If you'd like to add an avatar to all of your comments click here!

© 2014 Mark's Daily Apple

Subscribe to the Newsletter and Get a Free Copy
of Mark Sisson's Fitness eBook and more!