Meet Mark

Let me introduce myself. My name is Mark Sisson. I’m 63 years young. I live and work in Malibu, California. In a past life I was a professional marathoner and triathlete. Now my life goal is to help 100 million people get healthy. I started this blog in 2006 to empower people to take full responsibility for their own health and enjoyment of life by investigating, discussing, and critically rethinking everything we’ve assumed to be true about health and wellness...

Tell Me More
Stay Connected
March 07, 2008

Diabetes is Now a Disorder of the Small Intestine?

By Mark Sisson
38 Comments

I’m not a doctor… and I don’t play one on TV, but fer cryin’ out loud, when will they learn? I just want to SCREAM sometimes. Seems bariatric surgery as a possible cure for type 2 diabetes was not enough. Old technology. Now the rocket scientists have determined that surgically bypassing the upper part of the small intestine can cure type 2 diabetes even better than that silly old gastric bypass weight-loss “breakthrough” of just a few months ago. Read this Science Daily article and tell me I didn’t eat bad mushrooms in my salad today.

‘When we bypass the duodenum and jejunum, we are bypassing what may be the source of the problem,’ says Dr. Rubino, who is heading up NewYork-Presbyterian/Weill Cornell’s Diabetes Surgery Center.

In fact, it has become increasingly evident that the gastrointestinal tract plays an important role in energy regulation, and that many gut hormones are involved in the regulation of sugar metabolism. ‘It should not surprise anyone that surgically altering the bowel’s anatomy affects the mechanisms that regulate blood sugar levels, eventually influencing diabetes,’ Dr. Rubino says.

Surgically altering the bowel’s anatomy? People, the source of the problem is bad diet and lack of exercise. Full stop. I’ve said it a hundred times here. Give me 95% of type 2s and I can cure them of diabetes forever in 90 days if they simply eat and exercise right. It’s not easy, but it’s free and doesn’t leave you messed up for life. Life is all about gene expression. Send the wrong signals and your genes express themselves in the direction of diabetes. Send the right signals and you’ll decrease insulin, increase muscle cell insulin sensitivity and normalize blood glucose, burn fat and preserve muscle. And all the recent discussion here on MDA about “all the many genetic differences we are seeing in the human population” doesn’t change a thing. The fact that some of us are predisposed to respond to dietary changes slightly faster or slower than others doesn’t remove the fact that our basic biochemistry all works the same. Yes, that same way we were designed by evolution. Yet, Dr. Rubino is suggesting that this miracle surgery might be the only hope for millions of us.

In fact, bypass of the upper small intestine does not improve the ability of the body to regulate blood sugar levels.

[but didn’t he just imply otherwise?]

‘When performed in subjects who are not diabetic, the bypass of the upper intestine may even impair the mechanisms that regulate blood levels of glucose,’ says Dr. Rubino. ‘In striking contrast, when nutrients’ passage is diverted from the upper intestine of diabetic patients, diabetes resolves.’

So what does that mean for a new surgically-corrected diabetic patient who finally decides to eat and exercise correctly? I guess he or she is just hosed for life? You gonna reconnect the bowel now? So much for homeostasis. And here’s the kicker:

There is, in fact, growing evidence that diabetes surgery can be effective even for patients who are only slightly obese or just overweight.

Leave it to a surgical specialist to come up with a plumbing cure for type 2 diabetes that applies to all 20 million in the US alone. Even at only $30,000 per procedure, let’s see, that’s six hundred billion dollars worth of business. Nice work if you can get it.

This, he explains, implies that the upper intestine of diabetic patients may be the site where an abnormal signal is produced, causing, or at least favoring, the development of the disease.

How exactly the upper intestine is dysfunctional remains to be seen. Dr. Rubino proposes an original explanation known in the scientific community as the ‘anti-incretin theory.’

By the way, I Googled “anti-incretin theory” and got four results, all as uttered by Rubino, so it’s unclear how the rest of the scientific community actually even feels about this theory.

I could dissect the rest of the article – everything said in it makes me want to puke. I know the good doctor is a well-respected specialist, but that just makes it even worse. I’m sure there’s a bunch of surgeons already drinking the Kool-aid and girding (maybe GERDing) their loins for a new rush in business. I can just feel my cortisol levels rising as I write this. Maybe the good doc can find a way to surgically bypass my adrenals. Just reroute the plumbing, doc. After all, stress is bad, and lord knows there’s no other possible way for me to avoid stress in my life. Am I just another hapless victim of bad genes?

Speak to me.

harrymoon Flickr Photo (CC)

Further Reading:

Lap Bands and Type 2 Diabetes

The Definitive Guide to Insulin, Blood Sugar and Type 2 Diabetes (and you’ll understand it)

Sponsor note:
This post was brought to you by the Damage Control Master Formula, independently proven as the most comprehensive high-potency antioxidant multivitamin available anywhere. With the highest antioxidant per dollar value and a complete anti-aging, stress, and cognition profile, the Master Formula is truly the only multivitamin supplement you will ever need. Toss out the drawers full of dozens of different supplements with questionable potency and efficacy and experience the proven Damage Control difference!

Subscribe to Mark’s Daily Apple feeds

Subscribe to the Newsletter

If you'd like to add an avatar to all of your comments click here!

Leave a Reply

38 Comments on "Diabetes is Now a Disorder of the Small Intestine?"

avatar

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Matt Metzgar
8 years 6 months ago

The surgery/drug mentality in this country is ridiculous. It should be a “pre-requisite” for surgery that a person at least attempts lifestyle changes or becomes educated about the problem.

Scott Kustes
8 years 6 months ago

Excellent rant Mark! I give it a 9.5 out of 10. Needed more 4-letter words, but all in all, very rational and well thought out. 😀

To second what Mr. Metzgar said above, it’s all about “ease of use” in this country. Why should I exercise and eat right when I can have my (very intricately evolved) plumbing rerouted and blame my genes? It’s unfortunate that our fellow citizens have been educated that they are victims of their own bodies rather than masters of them.

Cheers
Scott Kustes
Modern Forager

McFly
McFly
8 years 6 months ago

There’s one other quote from the article that made my jaw drop:

“Type 2 diabetes, which accounts for 90 to 95 percent of all cases of diabetes…”

That means 19 out of 20 people have a simple way to fix a problem that’s costing billions in health care per year? Ouch.

I’d also like to mention that now when you google ‘anti-incretin theory,” the first thing that pops up is this post.

JDS
JDS
8 years 6 months ago
I work in the obesity research arena and there is another side to the story: 1) People unable/unwilling to make the necessary commitment to lifestyle changes should not be left untreated. Yes, most everyone would agree that diet and exercise are the ideal way to combat type 2 diabetes. But that doesn’t mean you leave people to develop debilitating side-effects or to die if they don’t make perfect lifestyle choices. 2) Researchers also seek to understand how the timing of food intake, energy substrate availability and energy expenditure affect the regulation of body weight and food intake. This website is… Read more »
Migraineur
8 years 6 months ago
OK, so, they want to take our omnivore’s intestine and shorten it to make it more like a carnivore’s intestine — and continue feeding the same diet? Madness! JDS – I am going to be brave and say flatly that I don’t agree with your first point. Doctors can and do fire patients for not complying with their advice. My doctor actually told me once that if I failed to follow a certain piece of medical advice, she would decline to treat me. So I simply do not buy that we should mutilate people who are unwilling to do what… Read more »
Kenny
Kenny
4 years 2 months ago

You don’t need to drop your cable TV (although it’s probably a good idea anyway) to eat primal. Not everything on my plate is organic. The MOST important thing is to drop all the processed food in favor of the less processed food. It’s not hard to buy pre prepared vegetables and greens and then combine them with pre prepared meat with a simple home made vinegar and olive oil dressing. Eating primal is as simple as you want to make it; so make it simple, and simply do it!

Grok on!

Mike OD - IF Life
8 years 6 months ago

Make people pay out of their own pocket for non-immediate life threatening surgery and you may have more people motivated to find alternate means….oh like say eating right and exercise?

chainey
8 years 6 months ago
Quote: “Cherry-picking pieces of research which support a hypothesis and disregarding other pieces of research does nothing to elevate one’s argument.” This is a fair comment. I’ve now collected many sites/blogs that occasionally cite reports and studies supporting the low-carb lifestyle. They seem very persuasive to me. For the sake of balance I’m interested in sites that will refer me to studies proving the dangers or harm of low-carb diets. However, the study has to be intellectually honest. Citing junk food studies that include huge amounts of sugar, simple carbs, deep-frying in vegetable oil, etc. then blaming the “artery clogging… Read more »
Aaron
8 years 6 months ago

Thanks for the comment, chainey. It is taken to heart as we want to bring a fair and balanced approach to all of our content.

sarena
8 years 6 months ago

So true, been there, done that! Type 2 diabetes was a lifetime ago (maybe 2 yrs) before changing lifestyle (oh and breast cancer too!!)

insulting
insulting
8 years 6 months ago

Im sorry but I felt insulted when you said It can all be fixed by eating and exercising right. That’s not true at all, i know about 3 people with Type 2 that also eat and excerise right but still have plenty of issues because of Type 2…you’re ignorant..not everoyne is the same and for most ppl with T2 eating and excerising obviously doesnt work

Reagen D. (@RedDesilets)
4 years 2 months ago
Type 2 typically can be treated w/proper eating (which doctors are NOT educated about and the diets they give patients will make it NOT get better) and exercise. I’m NOT ignorant on this issue as my husband is chronically ill with several things, including Type 2 Diabetes. Everything the docs asked, we did but he still got sicker and sicker every year. A few months with a WAPF member nutritionist saw him be able to drop one of two of his diabetes meds and reduce one of his heart meds. We are just now adding exercise to this routine. Stop… Read more »
Lucy
4 years 2 months ago

Just wanted to say “Thumbs Up” to your comment! Reagen D.

Mark Sisson
8 years 6 months ago
Insulting, Sorry you feel that way. I don’t meant to insult type 2’s. I do mean to insult an industry that thrives on selliing type 2 meds for the rest of their lives (our rerouting their plumbing). I’m afraid a “can’t do” attitude is what helps keep many T2s from fully exploring their health options. I bet if you gave me details of what your friends tried, I could show you where they might have attempted some “natural” method that was doomed to fail. Take it from Serena who commented just before you, or from one of my employees who… Read more »
donnyrosart
donnyrosart
8 years 6 months ago
I don’t know about anti-incretins, but you got me reading about incretins. There’s one called “gastric inhibitory polypeptide” that apparently prods the pancreas to release insulin during periods of hyperglycemia. I guess it’s purpose is probably to signal to the pancreas that the increase in blood sugar is from dietary sugars, rather than just a glycogen dump from the liver. When mice are bred without receptors for the gip hormone, they are normoglycemic, and are insulin sensitive, but react poorly to a glucose tolerance test, the digestive system being unable to warn the pancreas of the coming flood of glucose.… Read more »
Migraineur
8 years 6 months ago

Donny – that’s fascinating. So one could hypothesize that the effect of this surgery would be a decrease in obesity but an increase in all of the other problems caused by unstable blood glucose – reactive hypoglycemia, mood and concentration problems caused by low blood sugar, glycated proteins (from high blood sugar levels), damage to small blood vessels and nerves, heart disease, kidney disease, and blindness. In other words, you’d be unhealthy, but you’d be thin.

In my mind, there’s nothing scarier or more dangerous than taking a complex system and chopping part of it out with an ax.

Mark Sisson
8 years 6 months ago
Donny, Thanks for adding this information. It’s very interesting stuff. I agree with Migraineur that whether or not you can achieve a short-term fix by bypassing the secretion of one or more hormones or polypeptides you inevitably disrupt a sensitive system. As “Rube Goldberg” a device as the final human form is, it is a complex collection of feedback systems that ultimately fails if one or more of the loops is circumvented. May not be tomorrow or next week, but at some point the attempts at acheiving homeostasis are overwhelmed and the result is a breakdown. The operation was successful… Read more »
trackback

[…] unknown wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerptSeems bariatric surgery as a possible cure for type 2 diabetes was not enough. Old technology. Now the rocket scientists have determined that surgically bypassing the upper part of the small intestine can cure type 2 diabetes even … […]

Daniel
Daniel
8 years 6 months ago
Interesting argument. On the other hand, I do think it’s unfair to say it’s “all their fault” for people who are overweight and can’t get themselves exercising. It’s like the old school of morality, saying that a person must just have a weak character or something, and that’s why they can’t get exercising. How many times in a person’s daily life do they find themselves not doing things they should be doing, even simple things like letting the dishes pile up. Just looking at how challenging it is for many of us to maintain good habits in the basics of… Read more »
Reagen D. (@RedDesilets)
4 years 2 months ago

It’s not always weak character but MOST people do make bad decisions. And when they start trying to change, they can be overwhelmed if they don’t have a guide and give up. We have been there many times. Love love love my nutritionist and don’t know if we can get there. What is missing is people that are willing to get a second or third opinion from someone that is not a mainstream doc. Docs really ruined my husband but we are on our way to recovery, finally.

Kenny
Kenny
4 years 2 months ago

Not to mention all the misinformation from the FDA.

Dr. J
Dr. J
8 years 6 months ago
The advantage that surgeons have over much of medicine is that we can “comply” our patient, and not have to struggle with needing their cooperative compliance. It may not be permanent but often we get a result that will last a while. That said, I would not operate someone who could treat their disease as well or better with lifestyle changes. The problem for the general medical practitioner is, of course, people want easy, quick results and will not make those needed changes. What should we do? You know the real answers lie in societal changes, not just this “evil”… Read more »
Mark Sisson
8 years 6 months ago
DR. J, For sure it’s a societal change that needs to happen. We live in a world where nothing is our fault – always someone else, the economy, bad luck. I used to have a TV show alled “Responsible Health”. The premise was that your health was the single most important thing in your life, and that until you took full reponsibility – not blame, but responsibility – for your current condition, it was going to be extremely difficult to make any progress. If everyone were able to simply say “I take full responsibility for who I am and how… Read more »
Regina Wilshire
8 years 6 months ago
People unable/unwilling to make the necessary commitment to lifestyle changes should not be left untreated. Yes, most everyone would agree that diet and exercise are the ideal way to combat type 2 diabetes. But that doesn’t mean you leave people to develop debilitating side-effects or to die if they don’t make perfect lifestyle choices. That is due in part to repeated and continuous warning to patients that A) it’s impossible to do a carbohydrate restricted diet for any longer period of time and B) it’s an unhealthy diet to follow. Both are UNTRUE, yet repeated like gospel….repeat something enough and… Read more »
Sue
Sue
8 years 6 months ago
“Just looking at how challenging it is for many of us to maintain good habits in the basics of life, how can we just expect people who are already in the “bad end” of the scale with regard to obesity/overweight/inactivity to do a complete life change at will?” How about if their life depends on it or if they want to avoid going blind or if they end up having a few fingers and toes sliced off – they’re pretty good reasons to do a complete life change at will! Hopefully, if they do make this life change they do… Read more »
Deb
8 years 6 months ago

90 days won’t do it for me, but I do find that when I hit a certain weight my numbers climb. My magic number seems to be under 220 pounds..221+ and higher, and my sugars are nuts.

I eat clean (cut out preservatives/chemicals) and work out with a trainer 2-3x a week…exercising regularly more than 6 months, eating clean 4 months now…but my A1C is still high…My problem is as I’m losing fat, i’m gaining muscle. I can almost guarantee like clockwork, once I hit below 220, bam, my numbers drop.

I have a lot to undo

trackback

[…] Diabetes is Now a Disorder of the Small Intestine? – Mar. 7 […]

trackback

[…] Diabetes is Now a Disorder of the Small Intestine? […]

Rebecca
Rebecca
8 years 5 months ago
If you get cancer people have some compassion. If you get diabetes you have failed and are doing something wrong! You are treated that way by your entire environment that all have miracle cures… In spite of the Diabetes ass. and my Dr’s advice I used a high protein/low carb diet..it helps, it does not cure. And what about the Government that filled our food supply with chemicals and margarine/trans fats that probably some people are more sensitive to than others. What about the wheat and corn steeped in roundup/poison so that the field weeds are controlled? Or the cows,fish… Read more »
scott baker
scott baker
7 years 11 months ago
You people are a bunch of morons and sound like tom cruise on depresion. Modern science has discovered things like antibiotics and tests and treatments for many bad genetic traits that many people have that can not be cured by change of lifestyle. I personally struggled with my weight for years and as I got older slowly lost the battle. Ten months ago I had bypass surgery and can tell you it was the single best thing that I’ve ever done for myself. Period. It drastically reduces your chances of dying from cancer and cured my t2. And whats more… Read more »
Sue
Sue
7 years 11 months ago
“Ten months ago I had bypass surgery and can tell you it was the single best thing that I’ve ever done for myself. Period. It drastically reduces your chances of dying from cancer and cured my t2. And whats more I didn’t have to become a slave to exercise and diet. Keep up your rediculous fight to live right and I’ll just go on living happily normal and not being a slave to T2” How does it reduce your chance of dying from cancer and how did it cure your t2? When you say that you didn’t have to become… Read more »
Mark Sisson
Mark Sisson
7 years 11 months ago

Scott, I wish you the best of luck with the path you have chosen.

JD
JD
6 years 8 months ago
I’m a type 2 diabetic. People’s liberal use of “cure” is misleading. Going low carb, even undergoing surgery, will not cure one of diabetes. It does allow a Type 2 diabetic to get his/her diabetes under control. Either that, or the person has been misdiagnosed (ie, never had diabetes to begin with). But remains a chronic condition that is not cured. If it is true that one is cured of type 2 diabetes, then that person can go back to eating more carbs and still see his/her post-meal blood sugar remain the same as that of a nondiabetic. Of course… Read more »
Mark Sisson
6 years 8 months ago
JD, it’s a semantic issue. If one is obese at, say 350 pounds and loses 175 pounds, is one still “obese”? No. As long as that person keeps eating right and exercising, the weight stays off and the person is not obese. It would be ridiculous for that person to say “I’m obese…I just weigh 175 now…” Same goes for type 2. Once you get your numbers in line, you are no longer type 2. That doesn’t mean that you can’t reacquire diabetic numbers by eating crap again some day, but as long as your BG and insulin are low… Read more »
mm
mm
6 years 2 months ago

As someone with Crohn’s Disease I have to disagree with that.
Just because I’m in remission, medicated and have reduced my stress levels and eat low G.I., low fiber foods so that my trigger-happy immune system isn’t punching holes and fistulas in my intestines does not mean I don’t have Crohn’s Disease.
Unless I am misunderstanding what is the definition of “(insulin-resistant) diabetes”

Primal Palate
Primal Palate
5 years 4 months ago

I just stumbled upon this blog…holy crap!

Surgically altering the guts to fix diabetes lol…who would’ve thought.
Back in the 50’s and 60’s they used to take the colon out to ‘cure’ constipation.
(Fiber Menace, K. Monastyrsky)

Primal Palate
Primal Palate
5 years 4 months ago
To mm: My husband has Crohn’s Disease. He also has 52 hernias. He gets flare-ups when he eats GRAINS. The biggest offender is WHEAT / Gluten. If you have an illiostomy then eating low fiber helps so you don’t get plugged up. If you still have your colon you’re in better luck. But there are 2 different type of fibers, 1 of which is the offender, and the other isn’t. Insoluble fiber is the offender, the white stuff on oranges, nuts, mushrooms and everything else that’s a plant and isn’t chewed well. The flesh of fruit would be soluble, the… Read more »
trackback

[…] and diabetes, who knew? Diabetes is Now a Disorder of the Small Intestine? Read more: http://www.marksdailyapple.com/diabe…#ixzz2DAUWe8AZ __________________ I'd rather meander for the prevention than race for the […]

wpDiscuz