Meet Mark

Let me introduce myself. My name is Mark Sisson. I’m 63 years young. I live and work in Malibu, California. In a past life I was a professional marathoner and triathlete. Now my life goal is to help 100 million people get healthy. I started this blog in 2006 to empower people to take full responsibility for their own health and enjoyment of life by investigating, discussing, and critically rethinking everything we’ve assumed to be true about health and wellness...

Tell Me More
Stay Connected
June 28, 2017

Coconut Oil Is Going to Kill Us All (or Maybe Not…)

By Mark Sisson
112 Comments

Coconut oil and coconuts on a black backgroundI was beginning to rest on my laurels. It had been months since the inbox had flooded with upset readers asking me to address the latest episode of the conventional establishment’s attack on healthy food and living. Until last week, when people starting freaking out about the American Heart Association’s attack on coconut oil. As USAToday put it, “Coconut oil isn’t healthy. It’s never been healthy.”

I was surprised. While I get most of my scientific references from USAToday (the “Works Cited” section of my upcoming keto book is just a single link to USAToday.com) and they’ve never let me down in the past, I didn’t know what to make of their coconut oil claims.

Had I entered an alternate timeline? Did the Tokelau people of the South Pacific obtain 50% of their calories from PUFA-laden soybean oil, and not saturated fat derived from coconuts? Did the Kitavans thrive on an admittedly high-carb diet not by supplementing it with coconut cream and meat, but by dousing their yams and fish in Unilever margarine shipped in from across the ocean?

I did some digging, revisited some other sources I’ve used in the past. Turns out I wasn’t crazy. Everything was the same. The Tokelau people really did show zero signs of heart disease despite eating a 50% coconut fat diet. They really did start getting fat and diabetic and heart diseased only after the introduction of wheat, sugar, and vegetable oils. And the Kitavans did eat a high-coconut oil, high-carb diet and thrived while doing it.

I could probably stop this post here. I mean, 50% of calories from coconut oil and pristine health is about as resounding a debunking of the AHA’s position you could produce. Let’s keep going, though….

When it boils down to it, the AHA’s condemnation of coconut oil is just another salvo in their futile war against saturated fat consumption. They focus only on the tendency of coconut oil to increase LDL and ignore everything else it does, even referring to coconut oil’s lack of “offsetting favorable effects.”

LDL has something to do with heart disease. Maybe it’s the LDL particles. Maybe it’s the oxidized LDL. Maybe it’s all that and more. I just wish the AHA would branch out a bit is all. For example, you’d think the American Heart Association would find it interesting that PUFA metabolites are actually biomarkers of non-alcoholic steatohepatitis (fatty liver + liver inflammation). If you want a non-invasive way to diagnose it, just look at how much PUFA they’re metabolizing. They don’t. Maybe they haven’t seen the research.

It’s hard to blame them; their entire world rests on the foundational axiom that LDL cholesterol drives heart disease. If they question that axiom, everything starts falling apart real fast. Their continued existence depends on them not noticing “offsetting favorable effects.” 

About those supposedly missing favorable effects, coconut oil does many different things besides raise LDL, many of which are “good.”

Coconut oil consistently raises HDL in humans who eat it. Higher HDL is linked to protection from heart disease, and higher HDL:Total cholesterol ratios are often the best predictors of protection from heart disease, beating the AHA’s favorite HDL:LDL ratio in predictive power.

It even improves cardiometabolic status in heart disease patients—the group the AHA is convinced coconut oil will kill. Patients who ate coconut oil saw reductions in waist circumference and body weight and increases in HDL. Another study also found that coconut oil reduces waist circumference, albeit with the biggest effects seen in males. That said, an even earlier study found that overweight women were able to reduce abdominal fat using dietary coconut oil. Seems to be good for goose and gander, even if the geese have heart disease.

To the AHA’s credit, a doctor quoted in the USA Today article noted, “You can put it on your body, but don’t put it in your body.” You just got permission to rub it on your skin as lotion, make it into deodorant and apply it to your armpits, and use it to condition your hair. 

Personally, I put stock in actual clinical research into the topical effects of coconut oil—without the same fear-mongering around its dietary intake.

In hair, the shorter-chained fatty acids allow coconut oil better penetration to the hair proteins. This protects them from sun damage and results in less hair protein loss when compared to mineral oil or sunflower oil.

On the skin, coconut oil performs admirably against mineral oil in the treatment of scaly skin. It also beats mineral oil in dermatitis patients.

Oil pulling with virgin coconut oil (swishing it around in your mouth, making sure to get between the teeth, before brushing or eating in the morning) reduces the presence of cavity-causing bacteria in the saliva. Just don’t swallow.

The late Seth Roberts eliminated toenail fungus with virgin coconut oil. He applied a thin layer to the affected foot each day, then covered them with socks. This is just an anecdote, but we know that lauric acid—one of the primary fats in coconut oil—is antimicrobial.

In the interest of fairness, I’ll follow up with some negatives. Coconut oil isn’t a panacea.

It’s terrible for frying eggs. Maybe I’m doing something wrong, but my eggs always stick when I try to use coconut oil as the frying medium. No, I’m not adding the eggs too early. This doesn’t happen with other fats. The taste isn’t great with eggs, either, to be honest.

Coconut oil is not the same as whole coconut. The cultures that did so well on high-coconut fat diets weren’t eating spoonfuls of refined (or even virgin) coconut oil. They were by and large processing and using the whole coconut—flesh, juice, fiber, and all. It’s one of the reasons why I’ll often turn to coconut butter over oil, like if I’m making a curry. Coconut butter is flesh and fat and fiber. If you intend on emulating the Tokelau diet with 50% of calories from coconut fat, stick to whole coconut, not straight oil.

It does raise LDL. This doesn’t worry me, especially given all the “offsetting favorable effects,” but it may be an issue for certain people. Anytime you make a big dietary change—like suddenly eating a bunch of coconut fat—you should track changes to your physiology and biomarkers.

I will say this for the AHA: At least we can dispense with the accusations of conflicts of interest. After all, the coconut industry of America just pledged to donate up to $500k from coconut seed sales to the American Heart Association. For the AHA to come out strongly against coconut oil after getting such a sweet deal only confirms the objectivity of the assessment. Even if they’re wrong, they’re not biased.

Oh, wait. It was the soybean industry that pledged to donate the money to the AHA? Never mind.

Anyway, that’s my take on the latest AHA attack on coconut oil. What’s yours?

Thanks for reading, everyone. Take care!

phc_640x80

Subscribe to the Newsletter

If you'd like to add an avatar to all of your comments click here!

Leave a Reply

112 Comments on "Coconut Oil Is Going to Kill Us All (or Maybe Not…)"

avatar

Sort by:   newest | oldest
HealthyHombre
HealthyHombre
2 months 24 days ago

LOL! Yes, USA Today is … uh … trying to think of something nice … oh yeah, it’s colorful and has a great gossip section, if I remember correctly when I see stacks of them lying unread in hotels. I read that article somewhere though and it concerned me. When I get concerned I tend to eat a little more, so I had a couple of extra slabs of coconut oil that morning and immediately felt better.

Melinda
Melinda
2 months 24 days ago

AHA–does sound like the 1950’s–you think?

HASMUKHRAY MODHA
2 months 23 days ago

Here here I splash coconut oil on my toast with honey yummy for years! 🙂 🙂

Bob Niland
2 months 24 days ago

re: At least we can dispense with the accusations of conflicts of interest.

Read the paper. See if you can reconcile row 1 (F.M.S.) of the Disclosures table (Consultant/Advisory Board column) with footnote#3.

The AHA may have picked, as lead author, a person among the least likely on the planet to objectively reconsider the AHA’s dietary advice.

My guess is that the whole thing is really about massive liability management.

PrimalAtty
PrimalAtty
2 months 24 days ago
Good point, Bob. I don’t want to speak for Mark, but it seems that he effectively recanted the statement to which you referred in his subsequent paragraph, “Oh, wait. It was the soybean industry that pledged to donate the money to the AHA? Never mind.” Nevertheless, you’ve brought up an important point. Scientific studies would be much more reliable were it not for the biases of the authors. Granted, there are studies which are much more biased than others, but I continue to be surprised by those who blindly accept scientific research simply because it’s scientific research. They fail to… Read more »
Bob Niland
2 months 24 days ago

Thanks, PA. My comment was in the spirit of what I considered Mark’s obvious sarcasm, but yes, I wanted to rephrase it just as soon as I hit [Post Comment]. It is ever thus on the internet.

This paper is just dripping with COIs.

The spreading criticism of it can’t help but alert many in the general public to just how destructive AHA dogma can be (and not just on diet).

Shary
Shary
2 months 24 days ago

Am I the only one here who doesn’t like coconut oil? I don’t like anything about coconuts, not the meat, the milk, the oil, or the flavor. Never have. I usually cook with bacon fat or butter..

Does anyone else use sesame oil? It is supposed to have quite a few impressive health benefits, including the ability to reduce inflammation and lower blood pressure. I don’t cook with it much but I do like it on salads and a few other things..

scd
scd
2 months 24 days ago

I’m with you mostly. I’ve heard seed oils are bad, but I use Avocado oil for cooking.

Katie
2 months 24 days ago

Oh my goodness, you don’t like coconut butter? That is my absolute favorite treat!

Like scd, I avoid the seed oils. I love olive and avocado oils in dressings.

Crazylady
Crazylady
2 months 24 days ago

Coconut oil isn’t my thing, either: it makes my throat itcc, probably from mold contaminants.
I try not to eat fried foods. When I fry, I prefer bacon grease or peanut oil, like most Southern cooks. Olive oil is my choice for beef: it browns like nothing else and develops a sweet flavor in the meat.

Sesame makes salads stellar, from simple leaf lettuce through fruit salads and the belovef BAS. The darker, the better, and the Chinese make the best. Darn it, Shary, you’ve made me hungry.

tribal
tribal
1 month 13 days ago

You may just be the one who doesn’t like coconut oil.

anonymous
anonymous
2 months 24 days ago
Be warned that some coconut oil is hydrogenated. This is done in order to raise the melting point and keep it reliably solid at room temperature — in other words, convenience. Natural coconut oil will melt at 76 degree F, the temperature of a warm kitchen or a warm factory floor. If the melt temperature is 92 F, it has been hydrogenated. A big part of the benefit of coconut oil is its short chain sat-fats, however it does contain some PUFAs (which, as we know are, beneficial in small amounts), and hydrogenating destroys the beneficial dose of PUFAs —… Read more »
Rick A
Rick A
2 months 24 days ago

I often wonder how anyone associated with the AHA manages to sleep at night! If you consider all the people who have suffered an died prematurely because of all the unscientific and downright WRONG advice the AHA has been forcing down our throats since it came into being, if I had been a part of this mess, I would want to end my own life rather than ponder what I had done to so many innocent and trusting souls!!!!

gkl
gkl
2 months 24 days ago

I too have noticed that frying eggs in pure coconut oil doesn’t work very well. But, blending in another fat (butter, EVOO, lard, etc) in a 1:1 ratio solves the sticking issue.

Larry B.
Larry B.
2 months 24 days ago

Thanks for the EVOO/coconut oil blend suggestion – will try it tonight for dinner, even though I am guessing the AHA is still opposed to eggs due to their dreaded cholesterol content….

William Gensburger
2 months 24 days ago

I have found that eggs fried in coconut oil on low heat, turn out perfectly and no pan stick if you coat the pan first. I use stainless steel pans.

Ryan Parnham
2 months 24 days ago

My wife and I fry our eggs in coconut oil with no issue. We use a cast iron skillet, put a TBSP or two of coconut oil in the skillet on medium or just under medium heat (gas burner). I let the oil melt and then disperse it relatively evenly and put the eggs on and let cook them fairly slowly to over easy, shut the burner off and flip the eggs for a few seconds and they slide right off with no left over egg sticking! We’ve grown accustomed to the taste as well.

The Dude
The Dude
2 months 24 days ago

I’ve been using coconut oil from a jar from Aldi’s for a long time. I cook my eggs in it in cast iron as well. They never stick and I like the taste.

sue nelson
sue nelson
2 months 24 days ago
I’m a 56 yo female who has been primal/paleo for three years. I consume no refined industrial oils, lots of saturated fats, a good amount of olive oil, and gobs of coconut products — 3-4 cans of coconut milk or cream a week, 8 oz or more virgin coconut oil per week, cups of coconut meat, coconut butter, coconut flour, creamed coconut and whatever else coconut product I can find. I eat coconut cream or butter by the tablespoon full for a quick energy boost or to get me through to the next meal. Just yesterday I had an appointment… Read more »
Nocona
Nocona
2 months 24 days ago

Wow, you are kookoo for coconuts!

Do you “put de lime in de coconut and drink it all up?”

Susan
Susan
2 months 23 days ago

Only to stop the belly ache. 🙂

Katie
2 months 24 days ago

Congratulations! Those are outstanding numbers!

I’m with you on the spoonful of coconut butter, it can provide the tastiest energy boost.

Nicki j Allen
2 months 24 days ago

Where do you get all of your coconut products

sue nelson
sue nelson
2 months 24 days ago

My local grocery store, my local health food store, Amazon and, when I make it across town, Trader Joe’s

Vicki
Vicki
8 days 8 hours ago

I’m curious what your LDL was/

Dr.RhondaPatrickFan
Dr.RhondaPatrickFan
2 months 24 days ago
wildgrok
wildgrok
2 months 24 days ago

WildGrok can read, yes:
“Anyway, that’s my take on the latest AHA attack on coconut oil. What’s yours?”
WildGrok says after not so much pondering (*):
AHA bad, coconut oil good

(*) WildGrok can look up fancy words in WikiPedia

Joe
Joe
2 months 24 days ago

AHA has been doing a good job so far. Oh wait! I take that back. Bad science on my part!

Nicole Peri
Nicole Peri
2 months 24 days ago
My pre-diabetic and chubby arse (along with the rest of my body) have thrived on a paleo/keto diet for over 18 months. The change in my health and body are incredible and I have never felt better. This is the only time in my life I have been able to successfully stick to any “diet” and with so much grace (Haha). I seldom feel hungry. I am much more alert. Feel and am getting incredibly strong. About 30 to 40% my calories do come from fats; organic butter, coconut oil and olive oil alongside the animal fats that I may… Read more »
Katie
2 months 24 days ago

Congratulations on your success! I relate so much to your story- primal living is incredibly enjoyable and effortless. I am 42 and feel so awesome. It just keeps getting better. 🙂

Nicole Peri
Nicole Peri
2 months 24 days ago

Thank you very much, Katie! Ditto! 🙂

Krish
Krish
2 months 24 days ago

Oil is not a whole food. It’s a processed product. Eating a whole coconut is good for health as it comes with the fiber – the way the nature intended. Oil is like sugar, a processed product. A little bit like 1-3 tablespoons is OK but not a quarter or half a cup IMO…

OctoberAmy
OctoberAmy
2 months 24 days ago
Totally agree, Krish (“Oil is not a whole food”). Grok didn’t milk cows or coconuts and wait for the cream to rise to the top, any more than he concentrated out the sugar from a sugarcane stalk. A little good oil (coconut, olive, butter, etc) to cook in or season veggies is fine, but I still go easy on it, like I do bacon (the darling of the Paleo crowd but still processed), and those nut flours (Grok ate a handful of nuts after battling them out of their shells, not 2 cups worth in a cupcake). I agree that… Read more »
John
John
2 months 23 days ago
Krish, OctoberAmy: I wholeheartedly agree with your comments, but they bring to mind my little pet peeve in the paleo-sphere – “processed”. What does that really mean? It is used in a negative sense almost universally in the paleo-sphere, but it is so vague as to be meaningless. I’ve cured my own bacon, from healthy, pasture raised pigs, using nothing but salt. Technically processed, but I would claim very healthy. My point is: it’s the ingredients that matter, not the processing. If your ingredients are something you can pick in the field, or slaughter from an animal, you’ll likely end… Read more »
Jacqueline Ehrlich
Jacqueline Ehrlich
2 months 24 days ago

“Oh, wait. It was the soybean industry that pledged to donate the money to the AHA? Never mind.”

That comment alone was worth the read!

Heather Boroughs
2 months 24 days ago

That was absolutely awesome. I agree that comment sealed the deal on a fantastic article.

skeedaddy
skeedaddy
2 months 17 days ago

AHA motto: “Unfair and Unbalanced.”

Paleo Phil
Paleo Phil
2 months 24 days ago

The ADA recommends 13 grams of Saturated Fat per day. 1 tablespoon of Coconut Oil is 12 grams of Saturated fat.

I used about 1/2 tablespoons of coconut oil per day. I’m sure we will all be fine.

India
India
2 months 24 days ago

Your amazing!!! This was definitely a good read. I have a hard time with every other day something that’s healthy and natural is now all of a sudden bad. I live by coconut oil for its antibacterial and anti inflammatory properties. Still my favorite!!!

LOL LOL to the “oh wait. It was the soybean industry that pledged to donate the money to the AHA nevermind.” LOL LOL LOL

Tina van D
Tina van D
2 months 24 days ago

“Oh wait. It was the soybean industry…” ???

Tina van D
Tina van D
2 months 24 days ago

Ugh. Those ??? We’re laughing emojis when I wrote the post.

Larry B.
Larry B.
2 months 24 days ago

The AHA article referenced data discounting the positive effect of elevated HDL – probably so that they could justify their position RE the evils of LDL.

scd
scd
2 months 24 days ago

It’s a matter of taste. Coconut oil stinks, and some people use it in their hair overnight once a week or so to help w/ shine, growth, whatever, but I wouldn’t cook with what I put in my hair, lol! Food should taste good!

LlamaAnna
LlamaAnna
1 month 1 day ago

Do you not like the smell of coconuts, or did you get a bad or low quality coconut oil? High quality coconut oil doesn’t ‘stink’ unless you don’t like the smell of coconut. It’s an oily lightly coconut smell and that’s it.

Dee
Dee
2 months 24 days ago

A quote attributed to Upton Sinclair [my comments in brackets]:
“It is difficult to get a man [AHA] to understand something when his salary [funding or liability exposure] depends upon his not understanding it.”

Just think about the [class action] lawsuits that could happen if organizations like the American Heart Association or American Diabetes Association or American Medical Association, etc., ever reversed the faulty advice they have dispensed for the past half century. They will never reverse.

Pauline
2 months 24 days ago

All too true Dee. Same bad science and advice here in Australia.
Scum always rises to the surface unfortunately, happens everywhere.

Deborah
Deborah
2 months 24 days ago

Worth considering who funded the research.

“…..one of the lead researchers disclosed the following research grants:

California Walnut Commission†;
Ag Canada and Canola Oil Council†;
National Cattlemen’s Beef Association†….

……Another researcher disclosed the following research grants:

Amarin
Amgen
AstraZeneca
Eli Lilly
Esai
Glaxo-Smith Kline
Merck
Pfizer
Regeneron/Sanofi
Takeda…….”

Source: Robyn O’Brien

Time Traveler
Time Traveler
2 months 24 days ago

In short, all those who stand to loose customers who turn their backs on seed oils; same for grains growers and those promoting sugar and soda and process food.

Coccinelle
Coccinelle
2 months 23 days ago

There is also the fact that according to Chris Kresser, the four studies in this analysis were cherry picked from outdated studies. (1969, 1970, 1968, and 1979)

Susanne
Susanne
2 months 24 days ago

Coconut oil also removes mascara very well. Put some on a tissue or cotton pad, apply to eye for a couple seconds, and wipe. Clean eyelids.

TMSF
2 months 24 days ago
Aurielle
Aurielle
2 months 24 days ago
I’m an active person who’s been eating a nutrient dense, fish/seafood lc diet with moderate fat from olive oil/butter/coco oil for 40 years and always had a healthy lipid profile with very low triglycerides, high HDL, low-moderate LDL and total cholesterol. After 6 months of going slightly more keto a few years ago and introducing MCT oil, my thyroid levels plummeted, my (very painful) liver became enlarged, and my gall bladder EF dropped to just 1% above the rate at which surgery is performed. Altho my standard lipid panel still looked acceptable, an NMR showed my LDL particles skyrocketed from… Read more »
Clay
Clay
2 months 23 days ago

I concur. I think in the effort to combat fat phobia, the primal/paleo crowd can get a little overboard in the opposite direction. Saturated fat in large quantities can play havoc with your lipids. For some, or even many,slamming tablespoons of purified fats (butter, coconut oil, avocado oil, etc) won’t do you any favors.

Mike
Mike
2 months 24 days ago

Since we know that it’s the LDL Particle number and not the LDL number that is the issue, are you aware of any studies that show how Coconut Oil effects LDL-P? I’d love to be able to present that to the physician I work with and/or to my patients.

Time Traveler
Time Traveler
2 months 24 days ago

Good to know; I too had eggs sticking to the pan when using coconut oil and didn’t understand why. I now use ghee which is tastier anyway. And as far as the AHA, you are too easy on them. I stopped taking them seriously a long time ago.

Tami Zorge
2 months 24 days ago

Just looking at the LDL numbers is misleading because it doesn’t provide detail regarding the size of the LDL molecules. If they are large – not a problem because they won’t fit the smaller vessels – if they are small then they can enter the small vessels which clogs the arteries.

Julie Lobdell
Julie Lobdell
2 months 24 days ago

Coconut products make me feel good, inside and out. Last time I went to the doctor for a checkup she ordered me to not come back for at least three years. The while staff was shocked that I’m not on any meds though I’m in the “over 40” age group. That’s all the proof I need.

Your posts crack me up, Mark. Thanks for being awesome.

Conan the Barb
Conan the Barb
2 months 24 days ago

Mark – I think you and Dave Asprey and the rest missed this fact: the Tokelau do not eat coconut oil, which is a processed food. They eat the whole food which far more nutritious…the coconut. Just like olives vs. olive oil. The whole food has more nutrients and is not a processed source of calories.

Mike
Mike
2 months 24 days ago

He mentions that at the end when he states, “Coconut oil is not the same as whole coconut” and, “If you intend on emulating the Tokelau diet with 50% of calories from coconut fat, stick to whole coconut, not straight oil.”

Ida
Ida
2 months 24 days ago
I had a crazy rash on my skin….tiny little bumps and extremely itchy all over my body. No doctor could tell me what caused it and they all wanted me to go on rounds of antibiotics, some doctors even suggested steroids. I jumped on line and did some research….and went out to buy some virgin cold pressed coconut oil. I swapped out my beloved Neutrogena Sesame Seed oil and began using the coconut oil as a body moisturizer. In 24 hours…..24 hour hours(!)….the entire rash was gone. Gee…wonder why our health care costs so much?!
CaptainAwesome
CaptainAwesome
2 months 24 days ago

I love my eggs with coconut oil! Haha, I guess to each his own, but it is true that it does not do as good of a job as olive oil or ghee for non stick purposes.

skeedaddy
skeedaddy
2 months 24 days ago

Should the AHA motto be “Unfair and Unbalanced”?

L. Lee Coyne
2 months 24 days ago

The whole pseudo meta analysis was based on 4 studies all published in the 60’s. They rejected all others published in the las 20 years. Look up meaning of “confirmation bias” , “Cognitive dissonance” or “Revert to Authority”. Also follow the money.

George Henderson @puddleg
2 months 24 days ago

HI Mark, We wrote a bit about this here. One advantage of coconut oil is, that while it increases LDL (for the first six months only in rabbits – no-one has bothered to follow humaans that long) it decreases postprandial lipaemia, because lauric acid, being polar, needn’t go into chylomicrons. This is a part of risk, if there is a lipid risk, that’s unmeasured in standard tests, and is equal to a reduction in LDL to offset the fasting increase.
https://profgrant.com/2017/06/21/the-empire-strikes-back-american-heart-association-gets-presidential-on-saturated-fats/

Carine Dubois
Carine Dubois
2 months 24 days ago

I am slightly concerned about the age old acceptance of HDL as the good cholesterol in light of the recent failures of HDL potentiating drugs failure to decrease CVD. Could there be more to the story such as good and bad sub fractions as with LDL …. many more studies have to be done using up dated technology before accepting the AHA recommendations as dogma

Jamie
Jamie
2 months 24 days ago

“Oh, wait. It was the soybean industry that pledged to donate the money to the AHA? Never mind.”
Love me some Mark Sisson.

Anthony Jay
2 months 24 days ago

Best article Ive read on this topic. Thanks Mark

Mark Evans
Mark Evans
2 months 24 days ago

Heat your pan before adding your coconut oil, heat oil a little and then add the eggs.

Kerri McG
Kerri McG
2 months 24 days ago

Thanks for this, Mark. I knew the moment I’d read the AHA article (and the widespread panic on Twitter!)… FOLLOW THE MONEY TRAIL!!! Same with American Diabetes Association…

Nelly
2 months 24 days ago

As always, follow the money. The corrupting influence that moneyed special interests have on trusted institutions are the cancer of our modern age…

Charles
Charles
2 months 24 days ago
“The Tokelau people really did show zero signs of heart disease despite eating a 50% coconut fat diet.” “50% of calories from coconut oil ” The Tokelau people DID NOT GET 50% of calories from coconut oil!! The full paper http://sci-hub.bz/10.1016/0021-9681(81)90050-3 THE TOKELAU ISLAND MIGRANT STUDY: SERUM LIPID CONCENTRATIONS IN TWO ENVIRONMENTS “In Fakaofo in 1968 and 1971 the staples were coconut, fish, and breadfruit. Every meal contained coconut in some form- the green nut provided beverage, the mature nut either grated or as coconut cream was cooked with tare, breadfruit or rice. Fishing was one of the main occupations… Read more »
UrbanBuffalo
UrbanBuffalo
2 months 24 days ago

Thanks, I’ve been waiting for this post. My own family history of heart disease should should have me popping Lipitor by the handful by now, especially with all the coconut oil/butter/flesh I eat almost daily on top of all the other meat and nuts I cant keep my hands off of. And my oh so important numbers are still confusingly great. Perhaps all this isn’t a misguided fad.

Joan
Joan
2 months 24 days ago

What about coconut mea for humansl? I feed my horses coconut meal and have wondered if it would be good as another protein and fat source for me.. The horses love it and their coats are slick and shiny. They don’t get a sugar high from regular feeds and are more focused in their work.

Aafke
2 months 24 days ago

The people who did the study got money from the canola industry and big pharma. ‘
’nuff said.

Brian Van Slooten
2 months 24 days ago

Caution, oil pulling may cause dry mouth which would more adversely affect your oral health than any potential benefit. Oil pulling research is limited and non-conclusive, including the article cited.

Bill
Bill
2 months 24 days ago

I fry eggs in Lou Ann organic coconut oil with no sticking; they slide right out onto my plate. AMA’s version of fake news on the subject. lol I’m going to give pulling a try next.

Elsie
Elsie
2 months 24 days ago
Cate
Cate
2 months 24 days ago

Would love to hear your thoughts on Dave Asprey’s take that the issue over saturated fats like coconut oil stems from coconut oil “predominantly containing the wrong strain of MCT.” It’s in his blog post about this topic in the “Coconut oil is good, but…” section: https://blog.bulletproof.com/why-coconut-oil-is-better-than-vegetable-oil/

PaleoGuy
PaleoGuy
2 months 24 days ago
A fascinating article Mark. However the LDL detail is missing information. What are the effects of Coconut oil consumption on triglyceride levels, presuming the rest of the diet also avoids sugar and fructose sources? Dr Robert Lustig’s observations about LDL is that it isn’t all bad, only the “Small Dense LDL is, rather than the “Light Bubble LDL”. The only way to determine the levels of either is what the trigylceride levels are telling you. High triglycerides mean elevated levels of the Bad type of LDL. As usual, sound bites and half truths from American based and industry rigged ‘foundations’… Read more »
Lynda
Lynda
2 months 24 days ago

It seems like The Ancel Keys propaganda is alive and well. The general public is now aware (again) of how bad coconut oil is for them. They can now enjoy their soybean, safflower etc. oils knowing they are the oils to use for health..

Wepullup
2 months 24 days ago

I do all my frying in coconut oil now…it tastes amazing. Most of the negative studies on coconut oil are completely faulty!

wpDiscuz