Marks Daily Apple
Serving up health and fitness insights (daily, of course) with a side of irreverence.
12 Aug

10 Unnecessary, Worthless or Dangerous Exercises

PVLP156W 400x400 1Perhaps at some point in all our personal fitness careers (however advanced or modest) we’ve all had one of those “doh!” moments, when we realized we did something really stupid that now has us writhing in pain. (It could be an immediate or slightly delayed awareness – stuck in the recliner later that night unable to move. Anyone?) Sometimes these strains are the result of momentary carelessness, and sometimes they’re caused by ongoing ignorance (coupled with bravado or bad advice).

And then there are the exercises that maybe don’t leave us regretting our very existences but that seem to keep us (knowingly or unknowingly) endlessly circling the same fitness territory with little to no measurable progress. How come none of the other Saturday gym rats seem stuck in the same rut? What am I doing wrong?

“Bad” exercises invites a list much longer than a Tuesday 10 could fully accommodate, but we thought we’d throw out some of the most common. Any sound familiar?

1. High Tech Workout

WBLS

Possibly useful, probably not dangerous, but wholly unnecessary. There is absolutely no need to break the bank joining a fancy gym or buying large machines that will take up massive areas in your house. I mean really, $6,000 to go for a “walk to nowhere” when you could go outside and do the same thing for free? $4,000 to isolate one of the three heads of the triceps? You can get a solid workout with some free weights and overall conditioning programs like CrossFit. Little to no equipment. Excellent results. While some contraptions they come out with are fully useless (and sometimes comical), machines like Nautilus can get some people strength-training who otherwise wouldn’t go near the free weight section. Of course, for newbies healing from joint injuries, some of these machines may even be a preferable option for the short term. Talk to your PT and work with a good trainer.

Speaking of equipment…

2. Stairmaster Slump

2174013807 0d17c8fc62

Not limited to the Stairmaster by any stretch, we mean the slumped over bodies that hang sluggishly over handlebars, programming boards and any other part of the cardio machines that will hold their weight. Or how about those folks leaning back and holding the rails while doing 15% inclined walks on the treadmill? Do they understand that they’re not really doing the workout they think they’re doing? Is it some elaborate scheme of denial that keeps them going in this bizarre, unhealthy pose? Seriously, if you can’t fully support yourself during the workout, then you’re not doing the work or getting the benefit of the “program” you’ve selected. Get real with yourself, stop thinking about what you “should” be able to do, and change the setting already. What’s the big deal?

3. Chronic Cardio

treadmill 1 1

Ah, we know we’ve said it before, but we’ll say it again. Running (or stepping or spinning) yourself into the ground is an unnecessary exercise in exhaustion. A well-rounded exercise routine with a strength component, some low-level aerobic activity and a well-chosen occasional anaerobic interval training session will in nearly every case accomplish the same thing (or better) with less fatigue.

4. Strength Training with Poor Form

280741410 b1728b17ec 1

(Hint: often the result of too much weight.) If you’re arching your back under shoulder presses or moving at the hip during bicep curls, for example, you’re using poor (and in some cases dangerous) form. Not only are you not getting the full benefit of an exercise, you could be setting yourself up for injury or strain, especially over time. Another common mistake? Allowing your knees to pass beyond your toes during lunges and allowing your rear to go lower than your knees on the leg press. There’s a way to end up in the chiro or PT office! (Key: best to keep it to a 90 degree angle) Using poor form puts tremendous strain on your joints. Lift what you reasonably can while using proper form. If you’re jerking, arching, or staining unnaturally, go for a lighter load and get a trainer or resident expert to give you some tips.

5. Most Ab Exercises

Picture3 7

Think you need to do 200 crunches a day for strong abs? Think again. And think core instead of abs. This means the various muscle groups in the abdomen, the back muscles, and (for women) the pelvic floor. Crunches do work some of these muscles. Add side to side crunches, and you’re getting warmer. Even with the best form, they aren’t always the best option for your neck or lower back. (And they’re generally counterproductive for women’s pelvic floor.)

A strong core is as much about how you live as it is what you do for exercise. First off, use great posture throughout the day. Keep your abdominal muscles active as you walk, get up from your chair, etc. And go for activities that develop your full core. CrossFit is, surprise, surprise, excellent in this regard. Isometrics can do wonders. Check out Mark’s ab post. Other options? Pilates and swimming (Have you seen those Olympic swimmers?). More options? Yoga, belly dancing, Tai Chi to name a few. This is one instance when equipment is entirely unnecessary.

6. Spot Training (for weight loss purposes)

Picture4 6

If the spot you’re trying to train has a thick layer of fat, you can work it all you want, but you’re not going to lose any more fat there than you are in any other part of your body. Sure, it may look better because you have more muscular shape and structure behind it. Most people looking to spot train, however, want more definition, which necessitates less overall body fat – and that means dialing your diet in to where you burn off that stored fat. Strength train and do core work. Incorporate one or two days of good interval cardio training (under an hour), and fit in as much low-moderate aerobic activity during the week as possible. (The rest is what you eat, as Mark has said in the past.)

7. Unnatural Joint Movement

2326288388 470f48d041

As many Eastern practices like yoga, Tai Chi and other martial arts understand, the movements and poses work with the body’s natural abilities and alignment. Good form in all exercise practices takes advantage of this potential. Some exercise variations, like the behind-the-neck lat pulldown, do the exact opposite by putting unnecessary stress on joints. The motion of the “behind” lat pulldown, for example, works against the shoulder joint. It also compromises the rotator cuff muscles and results in neck strain. (But your body was trying to tell you that all along, wasn’t it?) Simple solution? Do the pulldowns from the front.

8. One Exercise Per Muscle Group

2721918085 ee6ca393d7

When it comes to exercise, variety is more than just spice. It’s essential for a balanced workout and muscle development. This is the heart of CrossFit and Primal Blueprint workout strategies. Nautilus and free weights alone tend to target individual muscles which can have its place. (We use them ourselves occasionally.) But it may be tempting, especially for wary newbies, to settle on one or two exercises for arms, one or two for legs, etc. This might be an improvement over a previous routine (couch sitting), but don’t expect it to offer the benefit of overall fitness. CrossFit builds strength (as well as agility and stamina, among other things) through diverse “functional movements” that utilize and develop the whole body.

9. Twists

293564516 edc3606572

Ever see those people going crazy whipping side-to-side with a broom handle across the back of their necks? Ouch. When done properly, twists may have some benefit for flexibility, but don’t expect them to make any difference in your waistline or do too much for building muscle in those areas. Now, if you controlled twists a little further, you might get somewhere. Work with a trainer to add movement in the lower body (more benefit, safer practice for your back) and a medicine ball. A solid, smart, exercise makeover.

10. Bad, Infrequent, and Poorly Timed Stretches

2607122550 d05828c18a

While some recent research suggests that stretching before exercise doesn’t prevent injury, there’s still plenty of good reason to set aside the time after workouts or in between sets. Maintaining flexibility will help you prevent the stresses and strains that come with everyday life and will help keep you limber as you get older. Stretching can keep muscles looser and more relaxed, which can improve posture, maintain spinal alignment, and promote relaxation.

Before a workout, simply warm up and use brief dynamic stretching (stretching through active movement – e.g. jumping jacks or plyometrics). Dynamic stretching is the epitome of warming up your muscles rather than relaxing them.

As for after and in between workouts? Stretch a couple times a day for full benefit. And remember that not every stretch you see in the gym (or learned in gym class so many years ago) is helpful. We suggest skipping or at least minimizing stretches that have you bend at the waist, which causes undue strain on the lower back. Standing and bending can perhaps be more problematic than many sitting poses because of the strain in maintaining balance and concentrating body weight as well as stretch effort on your back. Instead of putting your foot on an elevated surface and leaning over to stretch your hamstrings, for example, lay on the floor, raise your leg, and use a strap (or a buddy) to keep the leg steady.

Just as we suggest using a variety of exercises for strength training, mix up your stretches for the best all around benefit. Bored at the prospect of stretching? Find a good basic yoga class (or DVD).

Finally, by all means, don’t skip stretching the shoulders, chest and arm muscles. Tightness in these areas contributes to bad posture, which in turn precipitates back problems. (And so the cycle continues….)

When it comes to subpar exercises, it’s an issue of so many choices, so little time. Recognize some of the above? Have others to add? Shoot us a line.

Yogi, Big Fat Rat, andystoll, Hazel Motes, Carol Esther Flickr Photos

Further Reading:

Top 10 Health Marketing Buzz Terms (Ripe for Skepticism)

The 10 Dumbest Drugs Ever Invented

10 “Veggies” You Shouldn’t Be Eating

You want comments? We got comments:

Imagine you’re George Clooney. Take a moment to admire your grooming and wit. Okay, now imagine someone walks up to you and asks, “What’s your name?” You say, “I’m George Clooney.” Or maybe you say, “I’m the Clooninator!” You don’t say “I’m George of George Clooney Sells Movies Blog” and you certainly don’t say, “I’m Clooney Weight Loss Plan”. So while spam is technically meat, it ain’t anywhere near Primal. Please nickname yourself something your friends would call you.

  1. Great reminders. We all need a reminder not to get sloppy!

    Fit Bottomed Girls wrote on August 12th, 2008
  2. Money! This is one of my biggest concerns of late, having taken up the Primal Lifestyle. My body has adjusted to several years of 0 minutes or less exercise per day. Now that I’m working out regularly, I’m constantly trying to find the balance between useful exercise and overexertion. It’s good to feel the new soreness every time I try a new exercise, but then I get paranoid that my form is wrong and I’ve pulled something.

    McFly wrote on August 12th, 2008
  3. I have seen a lot of people at the gym do these herky jerky workout routines and they use far too much weight and in doing so do not come close to working the intended muscle properly. It’s important to be aware that working out muscles with proper weight and technique is essential. Just adding weight to look good in the gym will not offer up results like doing the exercise properly.

    James wrote on August 12th, 2008
  4. My (least) favorites are the stairmaster slump and the poor form. I don’t understand what these people think they’re accomplishing. It’s even worse when they proudly boast about how much they lifted or how hard they ran.
    Gal

    60 in 3 - Health and Fitness wrote on August 12th, 2008
  5. Good to see CrossFit getting props. The funny thing is, I’m the guy in the gym watching bad form and all the other crap and people have the nerve to tell me deadlift is bad for me…so is squatting, and getting my heartrate up too high.

    RUINER@DIABLOCROSSFIT wrote on August 12th, 2008
  6. I’d completely forgot about the twists till this post reminded me. I never really see it at the gym I’m with now but at my old gym there were a couple of broom handles placed near the weight lifting benches and mirrors. Almost everytime I used a bench someone would pop up behind me in the mirror and start doing the twists. A lot of the time I had to bite my tongue so that I didn’t burst out laughing and drop my weights. The whole motion just looks so comical when people do it in a fast, uncontrolled way.

    Tom Parker wrote on August 12th, 2008
    • hahahah :) !!

      sheni wrote on July 22nd, 2011
  7. “Allowing your knees to pass beyond your toes during lunges and allowing your rear to go lower than your knees on the leg press.”

    Does this rule of yours apply to full squats as well? They seem to be all the rage and really engage the entire lower section of the body. I’m pretty sure Grok could care less about the degree of his legs when he needed to do work. Sure, having a wide range of motion in the hips is absolutely necessary, but for those of us who can sit on our heels with no effort, why not use our full range of motion?

    see here for a published perspective on full body training:

    http://www.menshealth.com/powertraining/cms/publish/tips/1_Full_Front_Squats_are_very_effective.php

    aniki wrote on August 12th, 2008
  8. Unnecessary, worthless, dangerous and EXPENSIVE! Each of the machines must cost a few thousands.

    The machine from #1 looks like a crane. What in the world?

    Yongho Shin wrote on August 12th, 2008
  9. Most of those are seen daily at my gym. Even my own girlfriend routinely violates numbers 2 and 3. Unfortunately, these days, there are not many trainers around that will correct poor form. A trainer I know and respect says he has given up trying to get some of his clients to improve their form. He says they don’t listen and continue in their ways regardless of what he tells them.

    MarkFu wrote on August 13th, 2008
  10. Great list, although I do several sets of “#7′s” every morning. :)

    As for stretching DVD’s, I got “Magnificent Mobility” a few weeks ago, and it is truly magnificent!

    Tons of dynamic stretches, along with explanations of how and why they work.

    Geek2Freak Brandon wrote on August 13th, 2008
  11. what do you think about kettlebells?

    chip wrote on August 13th, 2008
  12. Hi. Great post. I am a personal trainer and the founder of PhysicalFitnet. If you would like to include clear, quality video clips right in your post to further help your readers/clients get lean, toned, sexy and fit, check out a new feature that we have.

    Sheryl wrote on November 24th, 2008
  13. I think kettlebells fall in the same category as “high tech workouts.” In other words, they’re more hype than anything. Not that you can’t get a good workout with them – just that they’re really not necessary.

    Stick with traditional weights and exercise routines and ditch the marketing hype.

    Hiram

    Hiram wrote on March 17th, 2010
  14. Thanks alot this helped the precious out 10 fold. 5/5 stars

    10 inch wrote on August 18th, 2010
  15. The NY Times just posted results from the largest study conducted on stretching prior to running/jogging (~conducted by USA Track and Field). Basically, you are right on #10. Static = Bad, Dynamic = Good… No drastic changes in your regime.

    Sean wrote on September 2nd, 2010
  16. Err…

    I’m a huge fan Mark; but re: #8, PBF seems to clearly promote “One Exercise Per Muscle Group” – at least at any given step in progression of the 5 basic movements. Yeah, you can add in WOWs and the legs are well covered with low-intesity cardio and sprinting, but (though I tend to agree with it) the PBF resistance part is not hitting lots of different angles. Thoughts…

    Jim wrote on November 27th, 2010
    • Huh? Pushups, hand stand pushups, squats, pullups, etc., are full body movements. They hit multiple muscle groups in large, natural movements. A pushup, for example, involves:

      Pectoralis Major, Sternal; Pectoralis Major, Clavicular; Deltoid, Anterior; Triceps Brachii; Biceps Brachii, Short Head; Rectus Abdominis; Obliques; and, Quadriceps.

      See, http://www.exrx.net/WeightExercises/PectoralSternal/BWPushup.html

      James B. wrote on December 10th, 2010
  17. That weird machine called the hip abductor and the other one that is the opposite way around (adductor). Beyond pointless. My (male) friend and I call those machines “the vaginators”. You only ever see women on them doing loads of reps with a low weight and I struggle to see how they replicate anything natural.

    Polecatz wrote on April 29th, 2011
  18. wonderful points altogether, you simply gained a new reader. What may you recommend in regards to your post that you simply made some days in the past? Any certain?

    stretching exercises for lower back wrote on October 25th, 2011

Leave a Reply

If you'd like to add an avatar to all of your comments click here!

© 2014 Mark's Daily Apple